, Decision_act (EU) 1998/251

In forcesince 21 May 1997

The assessment of the Commission will therefore be limited to the individual aid of ATS 5 million to CL towards the retraining of its employees enabling them to operate the chemical plant for the production of hydroxy-beta-lactone, and is without any prejudice to the position of the Commission on the scheme itself.

The amount of the aid is small, ATS 5 million (ECU 360 000) as compared to the cost of the training programme which is ATS 150 million for the first four years and covers at least 150 people. The aid intensity is therefore about 3 % gross.

The training obtained through the individual aid is of use to more than one firm and is by no means specific to the firm's operations. The aid should thus be considered a measure in favour of workers, even if a company benefits indirectly from it. Besides that, it is clear that owing to the financial and economic difficulties suffered by CL and the potential risk of job losses, employees of this company who benefit from the training aid have a better chance in finding other qualified jobs in case they lose their present jobs.

The position of the Commission on measures such as those to promote training and the acquisition of new skills is expressed in the Guidelines on aid to employment (6) which states that '. . . where such measures fall within the scope of Article 92(1) of the EC Treaty, the Commission usually gives them sympathetic consideration`.

Given these considerations, the Commission considers the proposal to grant the planned individual training aid to be compatible with the common market in accordance with the derogation provided for in Article 92(3)(c) of the EC Treaty.

E. Possible indirect restructuring aid to Chemie Linz

In its decision to initiate proceedings in this case, the Commission also considered that, were it to find that the aid measures were not compatible with the Treaty under the rules on aid for the environment or for research, the alternative question would then have to be asked whether it had to be regarded as aid to Chemie Linz, a company in financial difficulties.

As far as the notified aid for R & D and environmental protection is concerned, the Commission has found that part of it is compatible, on its own merits, with the common market and that part of it is incompatible. Accordingly, as the incompatible aid cannot be granted to HLR, it could not constitute an indirect aid to CL and the examination of this aspect no longer has any relevance,

HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: