Recital 87, Decision_act (EU) 1998/190

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

FAG has maintained that its refusal to authorise self-handling and to admit independent handlers was justified by the lack of space at the airport. However, as FAG itself admits, this constraint (supposing it to be real) is not insurmountable. Following the communication of the statement of objections in 1994, FAG, which had been informed of the fact that its monopoly could infringe Article 86 of the Treaty, should therefore have taken appropriate measures to solve the problems associated with the lack of space at the airport, for example:

–

FAG could have carried out adjustments to the existing infrastructure. This option was put forward by FAG itself in its reply to the statement of objections (40), but was not put into effect by FAG, notably because of the cost of the necessary investment (DM 35 million to DM 70 million), which would be passed on to airport users. On the contrary, FAG stated (41) that the airport had been designed and built with FAG's monopoly in mind and it had continued accordingly when successive adjustments were carried out,

–

FAG could have closed a limited number of stands (2, 3 and 4) in order to obtain the necessary space (see above). This option was not pursued because, according to FAG, such closure would have led to the loss of [ . . . ] slots, to the detriment of airport users,

–

More recently, FAG could have avoided reducing the space available for parking by more than [ . . . ] m² (over the period 1995-1997), as a result of adjustment work on the airport, and by more than [ . . . ] m², lost through the creation of buffer zones for cargo, following the relocation of cargo-handling activities to the south.

FAG could have allocated to ramp-handling activities part of the Little League area, which had recently become available, instead of allocating it to USAF Mail. Alternatively, FAG could have given over to handling services part of the area which is occupied in the freight area, instead of allocating it to Lufthansa (while the rest of freight activity moved to the southern area given up by the USAF).