Recital 67, Decision_act (EU) 1998/190

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

FAG's arguments fail in both aspects.

The Court of First Instance has already given a ruling in a similar case, taking a different view from that adopted by FAG. This was the judgment in Case T-30/89 Hilti of 12 December 1991 (25). That case related to the market for fastening systems used in the building industry. One of the questions examined by the Court was whether the market for nails was separate from that for nail guns, particularly as the products are complementary and as the manufacture of nail guns is protected by patents.

The Court held that 'with particular regard to ( . . . ) nails ( . . . ), it is common ground that since the 1960s there have independent producers ( . . . ) making nails intended for use in nail guns. Some of those producers are specialized and produce only nails, and indeed some make only nails specifically designed for Hilti tools. That fact in itself is sound evidence that there is a specific market for Hilti-compatible nails.`

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber) of 12 December 1991. Hilti AG v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    12 Dec 1991 · 61989TJ0030