Recital 102, Decision_act (EU) 1998/190

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

At all events, in its judgment in the Corbeau (48) case, the Court stated that 'the exclusion of competition is not justified as regards specific services dissociable from the service of general interest which meet special needs ( . . . ) and which call for certain additional services ( . . . ), in so far as such specific services, by their nature and the conditions in which they are offered ( . . . ), do not compromise the economic equilibrium of the service of general economic interest performed by the holder of the exclusive right`.

In this instance, the ramp-handling services are specific services which are clearly dissociable from the service consisting of the provision of airport facilities for aircraft take-off and landing.

In addition, it has not been demonstrated that the opening-up of the market for ramp-handling services compromises the economic equilibrium of FAG. Not only has FAG not provided evidence of the unavoidability of financial losses resulting from the opening-up to competition of the ramp-handling services market, nor that such losses would be incurred through the loss of FAG's monopoly; it is also clear that other airports are able to achieve financial equilibrium even though they allow competition on the ramp-handling services market.

Consequently, the financial-equilibrium argument put forward by FAG, namely the offsetting of losses in the landing and take-off facilities sector by profits in the ground-handling sector, is not relevant in this context.

B.4 The consequences of Directive 96/67/EC