Recital 10, Decision_act (EU) 1995/455

In forcesince 1 Mar 1995

Whatever their economic or social objective, the measures providing for a selective reduction in social security contributions referred to in Articles 1 and 2 of draft Law No 1536 constitute aid within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the EC Treaty, since they have the effect of reducing the costs borne by firms in the Mezzogiorno. They thus distort competition and are liable to affect trade, since they apply to all firms in that region. They are consequently aid that is prohibited per se under Article 92 (1) of the EC Treaty.

The Commission would stress, in connection with the so-called 'fiscalization` measures, that measures of a general character designed to reduce to cost of social security contributions uniformly in a Member State do not constitute aid. However, selective reductions that favour certain firms compared with others in the same Member State, whether such selectivity is individual, sectoral or regional (as in this case), do constitute aid within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the EC Treaty, at least as far as the differential portion of the reduction is concerned.

Although the reductions in social security contributions enshrined in Law No 64/86 were deemed by the Commission to be compatible with the common market pursuant to 92 (3) (a) of the EC Treaty in its Decisions on the compatibility of Law No 64/86, their refinancing for the period after 30 November 1991, particularly in view of the fact that they must be seen in conjunction with the 'fiscalization` differential available to firms in the Mezzogiorno from 4 June 1990 at the latest, and the differential itself, as contained in 'fiscalization` legislation after the adoption of Article 2 of the draft Law in question, are not in themselves compatible with the common market.

In its Decision on the compatibility of the Law on the Mezzogiorno, the Commission took the view that only the - already substantial - reductions in social security contributions provided for in Law No 64 of 1 March 1986 were compatible, because of the clearly defined circumstances governing the granting of such reductions. Such circumstances restricted the powers of the Italian authorities, which could grant firms situated in the Mezzogiorno total exemption for ten years in respect of each new job created, a general reduction of 8,5 % and additional reductions throughout the period of assistance - i.e. until 31 December 1993.

However, beginning with Decree-Law No 210 of 4 June 1990, the Italian authorities have granted such firms much larger reductions in social security contributions, through the legislative provisions on the assignment of contributions to the State. Firms in the Mezzogiorno have, by way of a reduction in social security contributions, enjoyed an advantage over their Italian competitors through total exemption in respect of all new jobs created, a reduction in the basic rate plus the 'fiscalization` differential and additional reductions. The average rate per firm was consequently around 27 % when the present proceedings were initiated.

This substantial increase in the reduction percentage which the Commission deemed compatible in the Mezzogiorno has significantly distorted the impact of the reductions authorized by the Commission for the benefit of firms in this region.