Recital 10, Decision_act (EU) 1995/452

In force

With regard to the distorting effect the concessions may have on competition, the Italian Government has calculated that under the domestic system of taxation the benefit would be equal top 48 % of profits, assuming the profits are in fact sufficiently high to bring them into the top tax bracket. This tax advantage would enable the undertakings benefiting to reduce their interest rates by comparison with market rates. The Commission considers that such distortion would not be strong enough to be contrary to the common interest; but it takes the view that this conclusion must be kept under careful review, as only experience will show whether the initial estimate of the extent of distortion was an accurate one. For this reason, and in order to limit the potentially distorting effect of the tax concession - it being clearly understood that purely speculative operations must be excluded - the total amount of aid granted must be subject to both of the following conditions:

(a)

the total amount of budgetary resources forgone must be limited to Lit 65 billion. The amount forgone is the difference between the sum actually paid in profits tax, local tax and indirect taxes on the transactions to which the special scheme applies and the sum which would have been payable under the ordinary Italian tax arrangements if the special scheme had not applied;

(b)

the total amount of loans or investments in eastern Europe to which the special scheme applies must not exceed ECU 3,5 billion.

The Italian Government is of the opinion that these two conditions are roughly equivalent (on the basis of a return of 2 % on loans or investments, taxed at 48 %). Given the relative uncertainty of the estimate of the tax base and the rate of tax payable, which may also vary over time, it is nevertheless advisable that the effects of the scheme should also be measures in terms of the investments carried out. The Commission further considers that for a proper balance between the costs and benefits of the Centre its operations must not be confined to undertakings with their residence outside Italy.