Although in the context of Article 85 a cartel is the combination of the participants towards a common unlawful end, so that the infringement is essentially a joint enterprise for which the undertakings must bear a shared responsibility, the Commission has also considered the role played by each producer and the evidence of the participation of each in the cartel. Full particulars were supplied to each producer in the course of the administrative procedure.
With the exception of Shell, all the undertakings named in Article 1 of this Decision were identified as participants in meetings by both ICI and BASF (10) and in most cases were also implicated in the 1980 planning document. Shell itself admits taking part in two meetings in 1983 (although its internal documents show that before this it was informed of the price targets) and that it was in contact with Solvay on volumes from January 1982 onwards. According to ICI, Shell was however the only important producer not in the compensation scheme.
The precise regularity with with the producers attended meetings could not be ascertained, owing to the refusal of the undertakings to provide the information requested. In any event, since the cartel was a venture continuing over a number of years, the fact that some members may have missed certain meetings or even took part less frequently than others is of no practical importance.
The document found at Atochem (as Elf Atochem was then known) shows that even after the Commission began its investigations in late 1983 virtually all the undertakings - ICI and Shell are the only likely exceptions - were still operating the cartel as before.
The fact that internal price documentation was almost non-existent at most of the undertakings first contacted in 1987 does not exonerate them from this aspect of the cartel's operation. The Commission does not accept that these producers could have conducted business in this price-sensitive product without any internal direction of their pricing policy. The degree of responsability borne by each participant does not however depend on the documents which - fortuitously or otherwise - are available at that undertaking but rather on its participation in the cartel seen as a whole. Thus, the fact the Commission did not obtain evidence as to the pricing conduct of certain firms does not diminish their involvement, since they are shown to have been full members of a cartel in which price initiatives were planned.
D. Procedural issues (27) In the course of the administrative procedure several undertakings asserted that the Commission had infringed their rights of defence by rejecting their demands for full access to its administrative files.
The Commission's position on this question was set out in the covering letter sent with the statement of objections to all undertakings involved in the case, each of which received all the documentation necessary to support the allegations made in the statement of objections together with a full set of replies made under Article 11 of Regulation No 17. The Commission also provided an inventory of the documents on file, indicating those to which each undertaking might have access if it so wished; but it was made clear that for reasons of confidentiality no undertaking would be allowed sight of internal commercial documentation obtained from its competitors under Articles 11 and 14 of Regulation No 17, with the exception of the documents attached to the statement of objections. The Commission subsequently and of its own initiative provided each undertaking with further documents which might be of assistance to the defence.
After the expiry of the time allowed for replying to the statement of objections, the majority of the undertakings made a joint approach to the Commission and, on the basis of reciprocal waivers of confidentiality, demanded that the Commission permit each to inspect all the documents obtained by the Commission from the other signatories. The Commission immediately informed these undertakings that they each had copies of the documents which they had supplied to the Commission and if they considered that any useful purpose would be served by reciprocal disclosure it would have no objection to their arranging any such exchange of documents amongst themselves.
It should be pointed out that any waiver by undertakings of confidentiality for their internal business documents is subject to the overriding public interest in ensuring that competitors are not informed of each other's commercial activities and intentions in such a way that competition between them is restricted.
Had there existed in the Commission files any document not disclosed to all the undertakings which could have cast doubt upon the allegations made in the statement of objections the undertaking from which it originated would no doubt have drawn attention to it during the administrative procedure. No such documents were forthcoming.
The Court of Justice has emphasized on frequent occasions (see e.g. Judgment of 17 January 1984 in Joined Cases 43 and 63/82, VBVB and VBBB v. Commission [1984] ECR 19; Judgment of 3 July 1991 in Case C 62/86, Akzo v. Commission [1991] ECR I-3359) that there is no provision requiring the Commission to divulge the whole contents of its administrative files to the undertakings. The rights of defence are fully protected if the undertakings have had the opportunity to make known their views on the documents relied upon by the Commission to support its findings in any subsequent decision. To the extent that in a decision the Commission bases its findings on documents not disclosed to the parties, that decision may be annulled. In the present case the Commission has gone beyond the requirements set by the Court of Justice and has disclosed to the undertakings not only the documentation supporting the allegations made in the statement of objections but has also provided them with documents (originating from one or other of them) which were not cited in the statement of objections but which were considered to be of possible assistance to the defence. These documents were relied upon by the undertakings and full account has been taken of them in this Decision.
LEGAL ASSESSMENT A. Article 85 1. Article 85 (1)