A volume control scheme continued until at least well into 1984, that is, even after the Commission had commenced its investigation in the thermopolastics sector in late 1983.
A document (drafted in English) headed 'PVC - First quarter' and relating to 1984 was discovered at Atochem (as Elf Atochem was then called) in January 1987. It lists the detailed monthly sales of the individual PVC producers for each of the first four months of the year and compares the achieved percentage market shares of each producer in the first quarter of 1984 with what is plainly a target share: '% T'.
The actual tonnage sales for January and February are headed 'final' whil those for March and April are headed 'Q'. It is apparent that in several cases the sales figures as the 'final' and 'quick' statistics as communicated by the producer concerned to the Fides information exchange. The Fides scheme is an industry-wide statistical service run by a Zurich-based accounting firm under which subscribing producers supply individual data to a central office which collates the information and produces global and anonymized statistics for the whole Western European market. From these global statistics each producer can determine its own market share but not those of competitors. The system contains confidentiality safeguards but there is nothing to prevent competitors from exchanging the information themselves in some other forum. The clear implication of the document found at Atochem is that the producers named exchanged their individual sales figures outside the official Fides system in order to monitor the operation of a quota system. Only in the case of ICI and Shell are rounded-off figures given.