, Decision_act (EU) 1994/291

In forcesince 27 Apr 1994

The complaint formally recorded was lodged with the Commission by TAT on 28 September 1993 and by the Commission's Directorate-General for Transport on 29 September, disputes the French authorities' refusal of 21 July 1993.

II In support of its complaint to the Commssion, TAT claimed that there was an infringement of Articles 3 (f), 86 and 90 of the EC Treaty, failure to comply with the Agreement of 30 October 1990 between the Commission of the European Communities, the French Government and Air France following the latter's takeover of UTA (Union des Transports Aériens), and an infringement of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92. The various submissions made by TAT include the following which are pertinent to this Decision:

–

French domestic traffic rights for flights out of Paris are normally granted by the French authorities for all airports in the Paris airport system designated for the operation of scheduled traffic rights, namely Orly and Charles de Gaulle (CDG). As far as domestic services are concerned, the French authorities want to encourage duplication of services, to Orly and CDG, in order to allow airlines wishing to do so to improve their services to Paris. By refusing to allow the same flexibility on the more important routes such as Paris-Marseille and Paris-Toulouse, the French authorities are effectively cornering the truly profitable French air-transport market for the Air France Group - and for Air Inter in particular,

–

the Air France Group's monopoly of the Paris(Orly)-Toulouse and Paris(Orly)-Marseille routes should have expired on 1 March 1992; point 1.1.1 of the abovementionerd Agreement of 30 October 1990 states that: 'in the light of the applications submitted, the French authorities shall designate at least one airline established in France other than Air France on the following domestic routes: . . . Paris-Marseille, Paris-Toulouse . . . . These routes shall be opened up to multiple designation with effect from the date of entry into force of this arrangement . . . the French authorities shall issue the required authorizations by 1 March 1992 at the latest'. Article 5 of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92 has not altered the necessary interpretation of those provisions,

–

Article 5 of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92 does not apply to the Paris(Orly)-Marseille and Paris(Orly)-Toulouse routes because: