Documents relating to fines imposed for infringement of the rules imposed by the shipowners' committees 1. On 12 February 1986 the Togo National Shippers' Council informed the non-committee Maersk Line by letter No 021/CNCT/86 that it had received a cheque for CFAF 1 032 255 in payment of a fine for loading goods without authorization in Marseille for transport to Lomé.
By letter of 25 March 1986 the TNSC noted that Maersk had loaded goods in French ports 'without the Secrétama stamp'. A fine of CFAF 4 226 847 was imposed; by letter dated 2 April the TNSC confirmed it had received the sum.
On 31 March 1986 the TNSC sent Maersk a payment form for a fine of CFAF 7 070 537, specifying that it was equivalent to 50 % of the freight value; the reason for the fine was given as follows: 'Goods loaded without Secrétama stamp'.
By letter dated 2 May 1988 to Maersk, the TNSC agreed to cancel two fines: one concerned goods apparently loaded in Marseille but which Maersk was able to prove were in transit through that port; the other concerned the loading of personal goods of no commercial value belonging to an agent of that shipping company.
On 13 June 1988 Maersk received a demand from TNSC for the payment of CFAF 3 098 750 for the unauthorized loading in Marseille of eight trucks.
By telex of 21 November 1988, the TNSC confirmed that a Maersk vessel that had taken on cargo in Marseille 'had been fined for failing to obtain the Secrétama stamp'.
In a 'Presentation Report' attached to a Senegalese draft Interministerial Decree of October 1987, the Senegalese administration referred to 'sanctions ... applied in our maritime trade with France'. In minutes drawn up by the France-Senegal shipowners' committee on 5 May 1987, Cosenam considered that 'the fines were not sufficiently dissuasive to prevent Maersk Line from loading', thus confirming that fines were effectively imposed.
The minutes of the meeting held on 2 July 1986 of the France-Niger shipowners' committee are headed as follows:
'Unauthorized loading by OT Africa Line (double penalties in the event of excess loads: fine and recording of results in statistics).'
The wording implies that if OT Africa Line, a member of the shipowners' committee, were to exceed its quota, it would not only be fined but the excess tonnage loaded would be deducted from its quota for the following month.
It is stated further on in the minutes that 'the Chairman pointed out that a Ministerial Decree provides for payment of a fine and confirmed that OT Africa Line had been penalized for the cargo under discussion'.
In the minutes of a meeting of the France-Senegal committee held on 2 June 1986, reference is made during a discussion on monitoring of cargoes not covered by the shipowners' agreement to the fact that Nedlloyd and Woermann had been penalized.