Recital 18, Decision_act (EU) 1991/301

In forcesince 19 Dec 1990

Following the hearing a number of further submissions were made to the Commission on Ansac's behalf. It was argued that an exemption for a limited period (two years) would allow Ansac to demonstrate that its behaviour in the market would have a beneficial effect on competition.

It was also claimed that the ending of the Commission's anti-dumping review without a finding of injury created a situation in which only Ansac, and not its members acting individually, could market United States soda-ash in the EEC without running the risk of a finding of dumping injury by the Commission: economies of scale would allow Ansac to show a higher nominal ex-works price than its members selling individually.

II.

LEGAL ASSESSMENT A. Article 85 (1) (19) The Ansac membership agreement is an agreement between undertakings of the kind envisaged in Article 85 (1). Any decisions or resolutions made by Ansac's Board of Directors under the agreement are decisions of an association of undertakings within the meaning of that Article.

The agreement has as its object and likely effect a restriction of competition within the common market with respect to prices and quantities. The agreement obliges the members to sell soda-ash for export exclusively through Ansac and prevents them from selling individually, with the exception of sales or deliveries to associated companies. The overall size of the United States producers, their low production costs (compensating largely for higher transport costs) and the fact that some of them have sold regularly on an individual basis show however that they could compete effectively among themselves and with the European producers. Their past sales activities show that they have, on their own initiative, been capable of overcoming storage and transport problems and assuring regular supplies to their customers. They are therefore capable of acting independently within the common market.