Pursuant to Article 155 of the EEC Treaty it is the task of the Commission, subject to review by the Court of Justice, to determine, under Article 90 (2) of the Treaty, which of the services entrusted to the Post Office constitute services of general economic interest. Under that provision, the rules of the Treaty and in particular the competition rules apply to the Post Office unless their application obstructs the performance, in law or in fact, of the particular tasks assigned to it. It is for the Member State to prove that the application of the Treaty rules would have such an effect.
Spain considers that if free competition were allowed in the provision of an international express courier service, it would jeopardize the financial equilibrium of the Post Office which is essential for the operation of the tasks assigned to it. In 1988, however, the Post Office's international express service - 'EMS-IPC' - handled only 20 000 consignments, representing only 0,00039 % of the 5 075 million objects handled by the Post Office.
At present, the international express service in question forms part of the EMS-IPC network which is operated by a company governed by private law competing against private international express couriers such as DHL, TNT, UPS and Federal Express. Although the network is faced with some competition, its revenue grows annually by 35 %.
Consequently, there is no evidence that the competition in the international express courier market could harm the basic postal service or that it is necessary to eliminate competition in order to preserve the financial equilibrium of the Post Office. The need to extend the dominant position of the basic service to the international express deliveries market, which is of secondary importance to the Post Office, is not an objective necessity justifying the elimination of competition in this market.
In reality the Post Office already enjoys considerable advantages, inasmuch as it has the exclusive right to install post boxes and issue stamps. In addition, public transport undertakings are required to cooperate actively with the Post Office in the general interest and, as the Post Office employs the same staff and the same infrastructure for the different services, it achieves economies of scale which have an appreciable impact on its prices. (14) In view of these considerations, competition in the international express courier market is not an obstacle to performance of the public service obligations imposed on the Post Office by the Spanish Government. The basic postal service monopoly held by the Post Office, which is not affected by this Decision is at present sufficient to ensure that the public service obligations are fulfilled without affecting trade to an extent contrary to the interest of the Community,