By letter of 4 April 1989, the Commission informed the German Government that it did not consider that the arguments put forward were sufficient to justify non-application of the framework in Germany. In its letter, the Commission commented on the arguments of the German authorities and invited them to reconsider their position. If they failed to do so, it would be forced to initiate the Article 93 (2) procedure in respect of all aid schemes in operation in Germany for the benefit of the
motor vehicle industry, with the objctive of enforcing the application of the framework.
By letter dated 3 May 1989 from the Minister for the Economy to Sir Leon Brittan, the German Government confirmed its decision not to adopt the framework stressing that, apart from the arguments advanced earlier, a specific framework for this sector is no longer necessary in view of the sector's current performance.
In view of the German authorithies' continued negative position on the Community framework, the Commission decided on 27 July 1989 to initiate the Article 93 (2) procedure in respect of all approved aid schemes currently in operation in Germany and available to the motor vehicle industry. In taking this decision, the Commission considered that the arguments put forward by the German Government were not sufficient to justify its failure to apply the framework, in contrast to all other Member States.
By letter dated 9 August 1989, the Commission gave the German Government notice of this decision and requested its comments. In accordance with Article 93 (2), the other Member States and interested parties were also given notice by publication of that letter (1) and were requested to submit their comments.
II
By letters dated 6 October, 31 October and 30 November 1989, the German authorities communicated their comments within the framework of that procedure. Furthermore, two meetings took place between the German authorities and the Commission on 18 October and 6 December 1989. The arguments advanced by the German authorities in order to justify non-application of the framework were the following:
The fact that other Member States approved the framework is irrelevant because for a number of them the framework has no practical consequences.