Eight Report on Competition Policy, point 1.7.6.
The gross operating profit criterion may be considered to be satisfactory in all six cases, since write-offs and financial charges can be financed from own resources, sometimes even leaving an appreciable net profit. The recovery is very noticeable compared with 1986, when the six undertakings recorded losses and indeed gross operating losses, with the sole exception of C3F, which achieved a modest gross operating profit of 0,7 % of turnover. These improvements reflect productivity gains, the rationalization of management and production (marked by an increase in the rate of capacity utilization and a fall in financial costs) and, in the case of Tréfilunion, the shift in production to higher value-added products.
In the case of GTS, the gross operating profit is sufficient to allow a profit to be achieved after depreciation and financial charges. It should be noted that the above forecasts are bases on cautious market assumptions. More than 90 % of this undertaking's market is accounted for by the oil and gas industry. That market is characterized by large scale contracts which are concluded in the light of the trend in oil and gas prices, which determine the transport requirements for such products. Such contracts can lead to significant fluctuations in turnover and profits. Recent trends indicate that the outlook for GTS is favourable.
With regard to the activities of CFEM which are kept in operation (corresponding to around 60 % of the 1986 turnover figure), it should also be noted that the gross operating profit is sufficient to allow a net profit. As with GTS, CFEM engineering is subject to fluctuations in its level of activities, depending on the conclusion of contracts. In addition, CFEM's activities comprise a higher proportion of project study and development and a lower proportion of manufacture than other undertakings involved in primary steel processing, which means a lower level of depreciations to be covered than in the case of other undertakings;
by closing several establishments and by concentrating or reducing capacity in various ways in sectors suffering from surplus capacity at Community level, the restructuring programmes for the eight undertakings concerned contribute to solving the structural problems facing the primary steel processing sectors and do not have the effect of transferring the relevant industrial problems and unemployment from one Member State to another;
in so far as the proposed aid is restricted to covering the costs of social measures for staff leaving the workforce and costs directly associated with the closure operations, it may be authorized.
The social measures relate to early retirement and non-active status allowances (1 906 employees), training and retraining leave (1 161 employees), redeployment (541 employees), redundancy (827 employees), the 'fonds national pour l'emploi' (73 employees), assisted departure (427 employees) and other measures (194 employees). Their total cost is FF 1 123,12 million (ECU 158,2 million). For the purposes of this Decision, as far as Métalinor is concerned, the Commission took into account only 80 % of this type of expenditure as corresponding to the EEC portion of the undertaking's activities (see point 11).
The costs directly associated with closures and with the reorganization of production relate to the closure and restructuring of plants, the demolition of buildings, the transfer and resiting of equipment, the termination of contracts in connection with closures, the handling of disputes and proceedings in this connection, capital losses on transfers of assets, and the depreciation of fixed assets (amortizations and stocks). These costs amount to a total of FF 502,6 million (ECU 70,8 million). In the case of Métalinor the Commission has taken account of only 80 % of this type of costs (EEC portion), i.e. FF 16 million.
The total amount of aid which the Commission considers compatible with the proper functioning of the common market since it meets the criteria for exemption provided for in Article 92 (3) (c) of the EEC Treaty is thus FF 1 625,72 million (ECU 229 million) out of the notified total of FF 2 783,6 million (ECU 392 million), of which FF 2 726,26 million (ECU 384 million) are assessed in this Decision as falling within the scope of the EEC Treaty.
The Commission considers that, up to this amount, which is proportionate to the scale of the problems to be overcome, the aid may be considered to contribute to the development of the activities concerned without adversely affecting trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest;
by contrast, examination of the other expenditure to which the French authorities propose to provide assistance shows that the aid threatens to affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest.
The expenditure in question is, firstly, that referred to under the headling of 'bridging costs', i. e. FF 481,7 million (ECU 67,8 million). Such costs are incurred in respect of the wages of the employees covered by the various social mesaures between the time when the social plan was adopted by the 'comité d'etablissement' and the time when it actually entered into force, after the necessary administrative procedures had been completed. It is impossible to check whether the employees concerned did or did not during that period contribute to the productive activity of the undertaking. Contributing to the cost of such wages would therefore entail the risk of covering the operating costs of such undertakings through State aid, which cannot be deemed to be compatible with the proper functioning of the common market in sectors suffering from considerable surplus capacity. The costs in question are, secondly, investment expenditure totalling FF 300,9 million (ECU 42,4 million) for investment to be covered out by Tréfilunion and GTS on the development of new products, research and development, anti-pollution and energy conservation measures and productivity gains. The costs also relate to State contributions to writing-off of past losses totalling FF 317,94 million (ECU 44,8 million). Such aid is directly linked to the re-establishment and maintenance of the future financial and technical structure of the undertakings concerned. Given the market situation in the sectors concerned, in which there is considerable surplus capacity, authorizing such aid would amount to giving certain producers an undue advantage and, consequently, to creating a distorsion of competition contrary to the common interest. The Commission considers that this type of expenditure forms part of the risk normally assumed by undertakings, for which the State is not responsible.
The total amount of the aid which the Commission considers to be incompatible with the proper functioning of the common market pursuant to Article 92 (1) of the EEC treaty is FF 1 100,54 million (ECU 155 million), since such aid is not eligible for any of the exemptions provided for in Article 92 (3) of the EEC Treaty.