In Chapter 5E of Part 13 of ITA 2007 (tax avoidance: disguised investment management fees), in section 809EZB(1) (meaning of “management fee”), for paragraph (c) substitute—
carried interest which is not income-based carried interest (see sections 809EZC and 809EZD for carried interest, and Chapter 5F for income-based carried interest).
After Chapter 5E of Part 13 of ITA 2007 insert—
CHAPTER 5F
Income-based carried interest
Income-based carried interest
Overview
809FZA (1) This Chapter determines when carried interest arising to an individual from an investment scheme is “income-based carried interest” for the purposes of Chapter 5E (and, in particular, section 809EZB(1)(c)).
Section 809FZB contains the general rule, under which the extent to which carried interest is income-based carried interest depends on the average holding period of the investment scheme.
Sections 809FZC to 809FZP contain further provision relating to average holding periods.
Sections 809FZQ and 809FZR contain a particular rule for direct lending funds.
Sections 809FZS and 809FZT contain an exception to the general rule for carried interest which is conditionally exempt from income tax.
Sections 809FZU to 809FZZ contain supplementary and interpretative provision.
Nothing in this Chapter affects the liability to any tax of—
the investment scheme, or
external investors in the investment scheme.
Income-based carried interest: general rule
809FZB (1) “Income-based carried interest” is the relevant proportion of a sum of carried interest arising to an individual from an investment scheme.
The relevant proportion is determined by reference to the investment scheme's average holding period as follows.
Average holding period | Relevant proportion
Less than 36 months | 100%
At least 36 months but less than 37 months | 80%
At least 37 months but less than 38 months | 60%
At least 38 months but less than 39 months | 40%
At least 39 months but less than 40 months | 20%
40 months or more | 0%
This section is subject to the following provisions of this Chapter.
Average holding period
Average holding period
809FZC (1) The average holding period of an investment scheme, in relation to a sum of carried interest, is the average length of time for which relevant investments have been held for the purposes of the scheme.
In this section, “relevant investments” means investments—
which are made for the purposes of the scheme, and
by reference to which the carried interest is calculated.
The average holding period is calculated by reference to the time the carried interest arises.
It is calculated as follows.
Step 1 For each relevant investment, multiply the value invested at the time the investment was made by the length of time for which the investment has been held.
Step 2 Add together the amounts produced under step 1 in respect of all relevant investments.
Step 3 Divide the amount produced under step 2 by the total value invested in all relevant investments.
Disregard intermediate holdings or intermediate holding structures (including intermediate investment schemes) by or through which investments are made or held—
when identifying, for the purpose of determining the average holding period of an investment scheme, what relevant investments are held for the purposes of an investment scheme, and
for any other purpose relating to the determination of the average holding period.
This is subject to the following provisions of this Chapter.
In this section, references to the length of time for which a relevant investment has been held are—
in the case of an investment which has been disposed of before the carried interest arises, references to the time for which it was held before being disposed of, and
in any other case, references to the time for which it has been held up to the time the carried interest arises.
For the purposes of this Chapter, carried interest which is deferred carried interest in relation to a person within the meaning of section 103KG of TCGA 1992 is to be treated as arising to that person at the time it would have arisen had it not been deferred as specified in section 103KG(3)(a) or (b) of that Act.
Sections 809FZD to 809FZP apply for the purposes of determining the average holding period of an investment scheme.
Average holding period: disposals
Disposals
809FZD (1) An investment or part of an investment is disposed of where—
there is a disposal of the investment or the part of the investment for the purposes of the investment scheme,
there is a disposal for the purposes of the investment scheme of an intermediate holding or intermediate holding structure (including an intermediate investment scheme) by or through which the investment is held, or
in any other case, there is a deemed disposal under subsection (2).
There is a deemed disposal of an investment or part of an investment under this subsection where—
under any arrangements—
the scheme in substance closes its position on the investment or the part of the investment, or
the scheme ceases to be exposed to risks and rewards in the respect of the investment or the part of the investment, and
it is reasonable to suppose that the arrangements were designed to secure that result.
In the case of a disposal of part of a holding of securities in a company which are of the same class, suppose for the purposes of determining which investments have been disposed of that the disposal affects the securities in the order in which they were acquired (that is, on a first in first out basis).
The references in subsection (1)(a) and (b) to a disposal are to something which is a disposal for the purposes of TCGA 1992; but for the purposes of subsection (1)(a) disregard section 116 of TCGA 1992 (which disapplies sections 127 to 130 of that Act in relation to qualifying corporate bonds).
Part disposals
809FZE (1) Where there is a disposal of part of an investment, the part disposed of and the part not disposed of are to be treated as two separate investments which were made at the same time.
The value of each of those two separate investments is the appropriate proportion of the value first invested in the whole investment.
The appropriate proportion is the proportion of the value of the part in question to the value of the whole investment at the time of the disposal.
The disposal of part of an asset includes the disposal of an interest in or right over the asset (and “part disposed of” is to be construed accordingly).
Unwanted short-term investments
809FZF (1) The making and disposal of an investment for the purposes of an investment scheme are to be disregarded if—
the investment is an unwanted short-term investment, and
the unwanted short-term investment is excludable.
An investment is an unwanted short-term investment where—
the investment is made as part of a transaction under which one or more other investments are made for the purposes of the scheme,
the value of the investment does not exceed that of the other investments taken together,
it is reasonable to suppose that the investment had to be made in order for the other investments to be made,
at the time the investment is made, managers of the scheme have a firm, settled and evidenced intention to dispose of the investment for the purposes of the scheme within the relevant period,
the investment is disposed of for the purposes of the scheme within the relevant period, and
any profit resulting from the disposal has no bearing on whether a sum of carried interest arises or on the amount of any sum of carried interest which does arise.
An unwanted short-term investment is excludable if it constitutes—
an investment in land,
an investment in securities in an unlisted company,
the making of a direct loan where the other investments specified in subsection (2)(b) are shares or other securities in an unlisted company, or
the making of a direct loan which is a qualifying loan within the meaning given by section 809FZR(2).
In subsection (2)(e) “relevant period” means—
for an investment within subsection (3)(a), 12 months;
for an investment within subsection (3)(b) or (c), 6 months;
for an investment within subsection (3)(d), 120 days.
But if at any time it becomes reasonable to suppose that, when the scheme ceases to invest, 25% or more of the capital of the investment scheme will have been invested in unwanted short-term investments which are excludable, subsection (1) does not apply to any investment made subsequently for the purposes of the scheme.
Average holding period: derivatives and hedging
Derivatives
809FZG (1) A derivative contract entered into for the purposes of an investment scheme is an investment, subject to the following provisions of this section.
The value invested in the derivative contract is—
where the contract is an option, the cost of acquiring the option (whether from the grantor or another person),
where the contract is a future, the price specified in the contract for the underlying subject matter, or
where the contract is a contract for differences, the notional principal of the contract.
But where entering into a derivative contract constitutes a deemed disposal of an investment or part of an investment by virtue of section 809FZD(2)(a)(ii)—
the derivative contract is not an investment, and
the subsequent disposal of the derivative contract without a corresponding disposal of the investment or part investment is to be regarded as the making of a new investment to the extent that the scheme becomes materially exposed to risks and rewards in respect of the investment or part investment.
For the purposes of this Chapter, references to disposal, in the case of a derivative contract, include any of the following events (to the extent that the event is not otherwise a disposal under section 809FZD(1) or (2))—
the expiry of the contract,
the termination of the contract (whether or not in accordance with its terms),
the disposal, substantial variation, loss or cancellation of the investment scheme's rights under the contract, and
in the case of a derivative contract which is an option, the exercise of the option,
but do not include the renewal of the contract with the same counterparty on substantially the same terms.
The substantial variation of an investment scheme's rights under a derivative contract constitutes (in addition to the disposal of the contract as originally entered into (see subsection (4)(c)) a new investment consisting of the contract as varied.
Hedging: exchange gains and losses
809FZH (1) This section applies where—
an investment scheme has a hedging relationship between a relevant instrument and a relevant investment, and
the hedging relationship relates to exchange gains or losses.
In this section—
“relevant instrument” means a derivative contract or a liability representing a loan relationship, and
“relevant investment” means—
where the relevant instrument is a derivative contract, an investment made for the purposes of the scheme or a liability representing a loan relationship;
where the relevant instrument is a liability representing a loan relationship, an investment made for the purposes of the scheme.
An investment scheme has a hedging relationship between a relevant instrument and a relevant investment if or to the extent that—
the instrument and the investment are designated by the scheme as a hedge, or
in any other case, the instrument is intended to act as a hedge of exposure to—
changes in fair value of the investment or an identified portion of the investment, or
variability in cash flows,
where the exposure is attributable to exchange gains or losses and could affect profit or loss of the investment scheme.
Entering into the hedging relationship is not a deemed disposal of the relevant investment under section 809FZD(2).
The relevant instrument is not an investment for the purposes of the investment scheme to the extent that the conditions in subsection (3)(a) and (b) are met.
But the termination of the hedging relationship is the making of an investment constituting the relevant instrument if or to the extent that that instrument continues to subsist.
Hedging: interest rates
809FZI (1) This section applies where an investment scheme has a hedging relationship between—
an interest rate contract, and
a qualifying investment held for the purposes of the fund.
An investment scheme has a hedging relationship between an interest rate contract and a qualifying investment if or to the extent that—
the interest rate contract and the investment are designated by the scheme as a hedge, or
in any other case, the interest rate contract is intended to act as a hedge of exposure to—
changes in fair value of the investment or an identified portion of the investment, or
variability in cash flows,
where the exposure is attributable to interest rates and could affect profit or loss of the investment scheme.
Entering into the hedging relationship is not a deemed disposal of the relevant investment under section 809FZD(2).
The interest rate contract is not an investment for the purposes of the investment scheme to the extent that the conditions in subsection (2)(a) and (b) are met.
But the termination of the hedging relationship is the making of an investment constituting the interest rate contract if or to the extent that the interest rate contract continues to subsist.
In this section “qualifying investment” means—
money placed at interest,
securities (excluding shares issued by companies),
alternative finance arrangements, and
a liability representing a loan relationship.
Average holding period: aggregation of acquisitions and disposals
Significant interests
809FZJ (1) Where an investment scheme has a controlling interest in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group—
any investment made for the purposes of the scheme in that company after the time when the controlling interest was acquired is to be regarded as having been made at that time, and
any disposal for the purposes of the scheme of an investment in the company after the time the controlling interest was acquired is to be regarded as not being made until a relevant disposal is made.
In subsection (1)(b) “relevant disposal”, in relation to a company, means a disposal which (apart from subsection (1)) has the effect that the investment scheme ceases to have a 40% interest in the company.
For the purposes of this section, in determining whether an investment scheme has a controlling interest or a 40% interest in a company, any share capital of the company which is held for the purposes of an associated investment scheme is to be regarded as held for the purposes of the investment scheme.
Venture capital funds
809FZK (1) Where a venture capital fund has a relevant interest in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group—
any venture capital investment made for the purposes of the scheme in the company after the time the relevant interest was acquired (and before a relevant disposal) is to be regarded as having been made at the time the relevant interest was acquired, and
any disposal for the purposes of the scheme of a venture capital investment in the company after that time is to be regarded as not being made until—
a relevant disposal is made, or
the scheme director condition ceases to be met.
For the purposes of subsection (1) a venture capital fund has a relevant interest in a company if —
by virtue of its venture capital investments the fund has at least a 5% interest in the company, or
venture capital investments held for the purposes of the scheme in the company have a value of more than £1 million.
For the purposes of subsection (1) “relevant disposal” means a disposal which (apart from subsection (1)) has the effect that the venture capital fund has disposed of more than 80% of the greatest amount invested at any one time in the company for the purposes of the fund.
In this Chapter, “venture capital fund” means an investment scheme in relation to which the condition in subsection (5) is met.
The condition is that when the scheme starts to invest it is reasonable to suppose that over the investing life of the scheme—
at least two-thirds of the total value invested for the purposes of the scheme will be invested in venture capital investments, and
at least two-thirds of the total value invested for the purposes of the scheme will be invested in investments which are held for 40 months or more.
In determining whether subsection (5)(b) is met in relation to an investment scheme, apply the rule in subsection (1) to the scheme.
In this section, “venture capital investment”, in relation to an investment scheme, means an investment in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group where—
at the time the investment is made the company is unlisted and is likely to remain so,
at least 75%of the total value of the investment is invested in—
newly issued shares or
newly issued securities convertible into shares,
the investment is used in a trade carried on by the trading company or the trading group—
to support its growth, or
for the development of new products or services,
and is not used directly or indirectly to acquire shares in the company which are not newly issued,
if the investment is the first investment made in the company for the purposes of the scheme, the trading company or group has not carried on that trade for more than 7 years, and
the scheme director condition is met.
In this Chapter, the scheme director condition, in relation to an investment scheme and a company, is that—
the scheme (or the scheme and one or more investment schemes acting together) are entitled to appoint a director (“the scheme director”) of—
the company, or
a company which controls the company, and
the scheme director is entitled to exercise rights within subsection (9).
Those rights are rights which—
are rights conferred under contractual arrangements—
to which some or all of the investors in the company are parties, and
which it would be reasonable to suppose would not otherwise be capable of being exercised by the scheme director,
relate to the conduct of the business and affairs of the company, and
are at least equivalent to the rights which it is reasonable to suppose a prudent investor would have obtained on making an investment in the company at arm's length of the same size and nature as that held in the company for the purposes of the investment scheme.
In determining whether the condition in subsection (2)(a) or (b) is met in relation to a venture capital fund, any share capital of a company which is held for the purposes of an associated investment scheme is to be regarded as held for the purposes of the venture capital fund.
Significant equity stake funds
809FZL (1) Where a significant equity stake fund has a significant equity stake investment in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group—
any investment made for the purposes of the fund in that company made after the time the significant equity stake investment was acquired is to be regarded as having been made at that time, and
any disposal for the purposes of the fund of an investment in the company after that time is to be regarded as not being made until—
a relevant disposal is made, or
the scheme director condition ceases to be met.
In subsection (1)(b) “relevant disposal” means a disposal which (apart from subsection (1)) has the effect that the significant equity stake fund ceases to have a 15% interest in the company.
In this Chapter, “significant equity stake fund” means an investment scheme—
which is not a venture capital fund, and
in relation to which the condition in subsection (4) is met.
The condition is that when the scheme starts to invest it is reasonable to suppose that over the investing life of the scheme—
more than 50% of the total value invested for the purposes of the scheme will be invested in investments which are significant equity stake investments, and
more than 50% of that value will be invested in investments which are held for 40 months or more.
In determining whether subsection (4)(b) is met in relation to an investment scheme, apply the rule in subsection (1) to the scheme.
In this section, “significant equity stake investment”, in relation to an investment scheme, means an investment in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group where—
at the time the investment is made, the company is unlisted and likely to remain so,
by virtue of the investment (on its own or with other investments) the scheme has a 20% interest in the company, and
the scheme director condition is met.
For the purposes of this section, in determining whether a significant equity stake fund has an interest of a particular percentage in a company, any share capital of the company which is held for the purposes of an associated investment scheme is to be regarded as held for the purposes of the significant equity stake fund.
Controlling equity stake funds
809FZM (1) Where a controlling equity stake fund has a 25% interest in a trading company or the holding company of a trading group—
any investment made for the purposes of the controlling equity stake fund in the company after the time the 25% interest was acquired is to be regarded as having been made at that time, and
any disposal for the purposes of the controlling equity stake fund of an investment in the company after that time is to be regarded as not being made until a relevant disposal is made.
In subsection (1)(b), “relevant disposal”, in relation to a company, means a disposal which (apart from subsection (1)) has the effect that the controlling equity stake fund ceases to have a 25% interest in the company.
In this Chapter, “controlling equity stake fund” means an investment scheme—
which is not a venture capital fund or significant equity stake fund, and
in relation to which the condition in subsection (4) is met.
The condition is that when the scheme starts to invest it is reasonable to suppose that, over the investing life of the scheme—
more than 50% of the total value invested for the purposes of the scheme will be invested in investments which are controlling interests in trading companies or holding companies of trading groups, and
more than 50% of the total value invested for the purposes of the scheme will be invested in investments which are held for 40 months or more.
In determining whether subsection (4)(b) is met in relation to an investment scheme, apply the rule in subsection (1) to the scheme.