Act of Sederunt (Rules of the Court of Session Amendment No. 5) (Causes in the Inner Hou…, 2

Causes in the Inner House

In force
(1)

The Rules of the Court of Session 1994 are amended in accordance with the following subparagraphs.

(2)

In rule 37A.1 (quorum of Inner House for certain business), in paragraph (2), after subparagraph (c), insert

(d)

an appeal to the court under Chapter 41 (appeals under statute)—

(i)

in the case of an appeal under Part II of that Chapter (appeals by stated case etc.), up to and including the procedural steps mentioned in rule 41.21(2);

(ii)

in the case of an appeal under Part III of that Chapter (appeals in Form 41.25), up to and including the procedural steps mentioned in rule 41.32(2).

.

(3)

In rule 37A.2 (procedural judges in the Inner House) for paragraphs (1) and (2) substitute—

(1)

All judges of the Inner House, except the Lord President and the Lord Justice Clerk, are procedural judges before whom proceedings in the Inner House shall be brought in accordance with Chapters 38 to 41.

(2)

In this rule and in Chapters 38 to 41, “procedural judge” means a judge as referred to in paragraph (1).

.

(4)

Subject to paragraph (5), in rule 38.6(5) (effect of reclaiming), for the words “custody, access” where they twice appear substitute “ residence, contact”.

(5)

Rule 38.6(5) as it applied immediately before 27th September 2011 shall continue to have effect in relation to any reclaiming motion which is marked against an interlocutor containing an award of custody or access.

(6)

In rule 38.14 (sist or variation of timetable in reclaiming motion), in paragraphs (4) and (5), for “shall” substitute “may”.

(7)

In rule 39.5 (sist or variation of timetable in application for a new trial), in paragraphs (4) and (5), for “shall” substitute “may”.

(8)

For rule 40.3 (determination of applications for leave to appeal from inferior court) substitute—

40.3. (1) An application for leave to appeal under rule 40.2 shall, without a motion being enrolled—

(a)

during session, be brought before a procedural judge on the first available day after being made for an order for—

(i)

service of the application on the respondent and such other person as the procedural judge thinks fit within 7 days of the date of the order or such other period as the procedural judge thinks fit; and

(ii)

any person on whom the application has been served, to lodge answers, if so advised, within 14 days after the date of service or within such other period as the procedural judge thinks fit; and

(b)

during vacation, be brought before the vacation judge for such an order.

(2)

An order for service under paragraph (1) shall include a requirement to intimate the application to the clerk of the inferior court.

(3)

Where an application for leave to appeal is served under paragraph (1), evidence of service in accordance with Chapter 16 of these Rules shall be provided to the General Department within 14 days from the date of service.

(4)

Within 14 days after expiry of the period within which answers may be lodged, the applicant may apply by motion for the application to be granted.

.

(9)

In rule 40.10 (objections to the competency of appeals)—

(a)

in paragraph (2), after “procedural judge” insert “at any time within the period of 14 days after receipt by the Deputy Principal Clerk of the appeal process”; and

(b)

in paragraph (4), omit “, and the Deputy Principal Clerk may refer a question of competency,”.

(10)

In rule 40.11 (timetable in appeal from inferior court), in paragraph (1), for “Upon expiry of the period specified in rule 40.7(1), the” substitute “The”.

(11)

In rule 40.12 (sist or variation of timetable in appeal from inferior court), in paragraphs (4) and (5), for “shall” substitute “may”.

(12)

For Chapter 41 (appeals under statute) substitute the following Chapter—

CHAPTER 41

APPEALS UNDER STATUTE

PART I

GENERAL PROVISIONS

Application and interpretation of this Chapter

41.1. (1) This Chapter applies to an appeal to the court from any decision of a tribunal other than a decision in the Outer House or a court to which Chapter 40 (appeals from inferior courts) applies.

(2)

In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires—

“appeal” includes stated case, case, special case (other than a special case under section 27 of the Act of 1988), reference or submission, or an application under an enactment by virtue of which a person may question the validity of a decision;

“case” means stated case, special case (other than a special case under section 27 of the Act of 1988), reference or submission;

“decision” includes assessment, determination, order or scheme;

“party” means the person appearing before the tribunal against the decision of which appeal is taken or any other person who has exercised a statutory right of appeal;

“tribunal” means court, Secretary of State, Minister (including the Scottish Ministers), Department, statutory tribunal, referee, authority or arbiter, as the case may be, against whose decision the appeal is taken.

Applications for leave to appeal

41.2. (1) Where leave to appeal is required, an application for such leave shall be made, in the first instance, to the tribunal which made the decision sought to be appealed against unless—

(a)

the enactment allowing the appeal requires the application to be made to the court; or

(b)

there are special circumstances which make it impracticable or impossible to apply to the tribunal.

(2)

An application may be made to the court for leave to appeal under paragraph (3) where—

(a)

the tribunal has refused leave to appeal and such refusal is not final, or

(b)

leave to appeal is required from the court and not the tribunal.

(3)

Any application to the court for leave to appeal shall be made in Form 40.2.

(4)

An application to the court under paragraph (3) for leave to appeal shall be lodged in the General Department—

(a)

within the period prescribed by the enactment by virtue of which it is made; or

(b)

where no such period is prescribed—

(i)

within 42 days after the date on which the decision appealed against was intimated to the appellant;

(ii)

where the tribunal issued a statement of reasons for its decision later than the decision, within 42 days after the date of intimation of that statement of reasons to the appellant.

(5)

An application to the court for leave to appeal shall include a statement setting out the proposed grounds of appeal and the grounds on which leave to appeal is sought.

(6)

There shall be lodged with an application to the court under paragraph (3)—

(a)

a process in accordance with rule 4.4 (steps of process);

(b)

where applicable—

(i)

evidence that leave to appeal has been refused by the tribunal;

(ii)

a copy of the grounds of appeal submitted to the tribunal; and

(iii)

any note by the tribunal setting out the reasons for its refusal;

(c)

a copy of the document issued by the tribunal setting out the decision complained of and any reasons for that decision; and

(d)

where the tribunal itself exercised an appellate function, a copy of the decision of the tribunal from which that appeal was taken and any reasons given for that decision.

Determination of applications for leave to appeal

41.3. (1) An application for leave to appeal under rule 41.2 shall, without a motion being enrolled—

(a)

during session, be brought before a procedural judge on the first available day after being made for an order for—

(i)

service of the application on the respondent and such other person as the procedural judge thinks fit within 7 days of the date of the order or such other period as the procedural judge thinks fit; and

(ii)

any person on whom the application has been served, to lodge answers, if so advised, within 14 days after the date of service or within such other period as the procedural judge thinks fit; and

(b)

during vacation, be brought before the vacation judge for such an order.

(2)

An order for service under paragraph (1) shall include a requirement to intimate the application to the clerk of the tribunal.

(3)

Where an application for leave to appeal is served under paragraph (1), evidence of service in accordance with Chapter 16 of these Rules shall be provided to the General Department within 14 days from the date of service.

(4)

Paragraph (5) applies where an enactment—

(a)

provides that leave to appeal is required;

(b)

does not prescribe a period for lodging an application for leave to appeal; and

(c)

prescribes a period for lodging an appeal which is shorter than the period mentioned in rule 41.2(4)(b).

(5)

A procedural judge or, as the case may be, the vacation judge may order that answers may be lodged to the application for leave to appeal within such period as he or she considers appropriate, having regard to the need for the application for leave to appeal to be dealt with before the period prescribed for lodging an appeal.

(6)

Within 14 days after expiry of the period within which answers may be lodged, the applicant may apply by motion to a procedural judge for the application to be granted.

(7)

Where an application for leave to appeal has been granted—

(a)

the Deputy Principal Clerk shall send a certified copy of the interlocutor granting the application to the tribunal; and

(b)

in an appeal by stated case, within 14 days after the date on which the certified copy of the interlocutor was sent to it, the tribunal shall state a case in accordance with rule 41.12 (preparation and issue of the case).

(8)

Where an application for leave to appeal has been refused, the Deputy Principal Clerk shall send to the tribunal a copy of the interlocutor refusing the application.

Urgent disposal of appeal

41.4. (1) Where the appellant or a respondent seeks urgent disposal of an appeal, he or she shall apply by motion for urgent disposal of the appeal, specifying in the motion whether the appellant or respondent seeks urgent disposal on the Summar Roll or urgent disposal in the Single Bills.

(2)

An application under paragraph (1) may be made—

(a)

in an appeal under Part II of this Chapter, at any time before the expiry of the period of 14 days from the date intimation is given of the lodging of the case under rule 41.14(1)(b) (intimation of the lodging of the case in court);

(b)

in an appeal under Part III of this Chapter, not later than three days after the expiry of the period allowed for lodging answers to the appeal.

(3)

The entry in the rolls in respect of a motion for urgent disposal under this rule shall be starred; and the motion shall call before a procedural judge.

(4)

At the hearing of the motion, the parties shall provide the procedural judge with an assessment of the likely duration of the hearing to determine the appeal.

(5)

The procedural judge may—

(a)

grant the motion for urgent disposal and either appoint the cause to the Summar Roll for hearing or direct that the cause be heard in the Single Bills;

(b)

refuse the motion for urgent disposal.

(6)

Where the procedural judge grants the motion for urgent disposal, he or she may make such order as to the future procedure in and, if appropriate, timetabling of, the appeal as he or she thinks fit.

(7)

The following rules apply to an appeal in respect of which the procedural judge has granted a motion for urgent disposal only to the extent that he or she so directs—

(a)

rule 41.5 (competency of appeals);

(b)

in an appeal under Part II of this Chapter, rules 41.18 to 41.21.

(c)

in an appeal under Part III of this Chapter, rules 41.29 to 41.32.

Competency of appeals

41.5. (1) Any party other than the appellant may object to the competency of an appeal made in accordance with this Chapter by lodging in process and serving on the appellant a note of objection in Form 41.5.

(2)

A note of objection referred to in paragraph (1) may be lodged—

(a)

in an appeal dealt with under Part II of this Chapter, at any time before the expiry of the period of 14 days from the date intimation is given of the lodging of the case under rule 41.14(1)(b) (intimation of the lodging of the case in court); or

(b)

in an appeal dealt with under Part III of this Chapter, at any time before the expiry of the period of 14 days from the date of service of the appeal under rule 41.27.

(3)

Where the Deputy Principal Clerk considers that an appeal made under this Chapter may be incompetent he may refer the question of competency to a procedural judge—

(a)

in an appeal dealt with under Part II of this Chapter, at any time within the period of 14 days from the date the case is lodged under rule 41.14; or

(b)

in an appeal dealt with under Part III of this Chapter, at any time within the period of 14 days from the date the appeal is lodged under rule 41.26.

(4)

Where the Deputy Principal Clerk refers a question of competency, he shall intimate to the parties the grounds on which he considers that question of competency arises.

(5)

Where a note of objection is lodged, or the Deputy Principal Clerk refers a question of competency, the Keeper of the Rolls shall—

(a)

allocate a diet for a hearing before a procedural judge; and

(b)

intimate the date and time of that diet to the parties.

(6)

Each party shall, within the period of 14 days after the date on which a note of objection is lodged or a question of competency is referred by the Deputy Principal Clerk, lodge in process and serve on the other party a note of argument giving fair notice of the submissions which the party intends to make as to competency.

(7)

At the hearing allocated under paragraph (5), the procedural judge may—

(a)

refuse the appeal as incompetent;

(b)

direct that the appeal is to proceed as if the note of objection had not been lodged or the question not been referred, whether under reservation of the question of competency or having found the appeal to be competent; or

(c)

refer the question of competency to a bench of three or more judges;

and the procedural judge may make such order as to expenses or otherwise as he or she thinks fit.

(8)

Where a procedural judge refers a question of competency under paragraph (7)(c), the cause shall be put out for a hearing in the Single Bills before a Division of the Inner House composed of three or more judges.

(9)

At the hearing in the Single Bills arranged under paragraph (8), the Inner House may—

(a)

dispose of the objection to competency;

(b)

appoint the cause to the Summar Roll for a hearing on the objection;

(c)

reserve the objection until grounds of appeal have been lodged and order such grounds to be lodged;

(d)

reserve the objection for hearing with the merits.

Intimation of final interlocutor

41.6. (1) The Deputy Principal Clerk shall send to the tribunal a copy of the final interlocutor in an appeal under this Chapter.

PART II

APPEALS BY STATED CASE ETC.

Application and interpretation of this Part

41.7. (1) Subject to the provisions of the enactment providing for appeal and to Parts III to XIII, this Part shall regulate the procedure in—

(a)

an appeal by stated case, special case, case, reference or submission against the decision of a tribunal;

(b)

a case stated by an arbiter;

(c)

all statutory proceedings for obtaining the opinion of the court on a question before the issue of a decision by a tribunal or by appeal against such a decision; and

(d)

a case required to be stated by a tribunal referred to in subsection (1), as modified by subsection (7), of section 11 of the Tribunals and Inquiries Act 1992.

Applications for case

41.8. (1) An application for a case for the opinion of the court on any question shall be made by minute setting out the question on which the case is applied for.

(2)

A minute under paragraph (1) shall be sent to the clerk of the tribunal—

(a)

where the application must be made before the issue of the decision of the tribunal, at any time before the issue of the decision;

(b)

where the application may be made after the issue of the decision of the tribunal, within the period mentioned in paragraph (3); or

(c)

where, in a cause in which a statement of the reasons for the decision was given later than the issue of the decision, the application may be made after the issue of that statement, within the period mentioned in paragraph (3).

(3)

The period referred to in paragraph (2)(b) and (c) is—

(a)

the period prescribed by the enactment under which the appeal is made; or

(b)

where no such period is prescribed, within 14 days after the issue of the decision or statement of reasons, as the case may be.

Additional questions by other parties

41.9. (1) On receipt of an application under rule 41.8 (applications for case), the clerk of the tribunal shall send a copy of the minute to every other party.

(2)

Within 14 days after the date on which the clerk of the tribunal complied with paragraph (1), any other party may lodge with the clerk a minute setting out any additional question he or she proposes for the case; and on so doing he or she shall send a copy of it to every other party.

Consideration of application by tribunal

41.10. (1) Within 21 days after the expiry of the period allowed for lodging a minute under rule 41.9(2) (additional questions by other parties), the tribunal shall—

(a)

decide to state a case on the basis of the questions set out in the application for a case under rule 41.8(1) and any minute under rule 41.9(2);

(b)

refuse to state a case on a proposed question where it is of the opinion that that question—

(i)

does not arise;

(ii)

does not require to be decided for the purposes of the appeal; or

(iii)

is frivolous; or

(c)

where the application under rule 41.8(1) is made before the facts have been ascertained and the tribunal is of the opinion that it is necessary or expedient that the facts should be ascertained before the application is disposed of, defer further consideration of the application until the facts have been ascertained by it.

(2)

Where the tribunal has deferred a decision under paragraph (1)(c), it shall, within 14 days after it has ascertained the facts, decide whether to state or refuse to state a case.

(3)

Where the tribunal makes a decision under paragraph (1) or (2), the clerk of the tribunal shall intimate that decision to each party.

(4)

Where the tribunal has refused to state a case on any question, there shall be sent to the applicant with the intimation under paragraph (3)—

(a)

a certificate specifying—

(i)

the date of the decision of the tribunal; and

(ii)

the reasons for refusal; and

(b)

where the refusal has been made after the facts have been ascertained, a note of the proposed findings-in-fact on which the tribunal proposes to base its decision; or

(c)

where the refusal has been made before the facts have been ascertained, a note of, or sufficient reference to, the averments of the parties in the appeal on which the refusal is based.

Procedure for ordaining tribunal to state a case

41.11. (1) Where the tribunal has refused to state a case on any question, the party whose application has been refused may, within 14 days after the date on which intimation of such refusal was made under rule 41.10(3), lodge in the General Department—

(a)

an application by note to a procedural judge for an order to require the other party to show cause why a case should not be stated;

(b)

the certificate and any note issued under rule 41.10(4); and

(c)

a process in accordance with rule 4.4 (steps of process).

(2)

A note under paragraph (1)(a) shall—

(a)

state briefly the grounds on which the application is made; and

(b)

specify the order and any incidental order sought.

(3)

An application under paragraph (1) shall be placed before a procedural judge on the first available day after the date on which the note under paragraph (1)(a) was lodged for an order for service of the note on—

(a)

the tribunal; and

(b)

every other party.

(4)

After the period for lodging answers has expired, the procedural judge shall, on a motion by the noter, without hearing parties—

(a)

appoint the note to the Summar Roll for hearing; or

(b)

direct that the note be heard in the Single Bills.

(5)

The noter shall intimate the decision of the procedural judge on the note to the tribunal.

Preparation and issue of the case

41.12. (1) Where the tribunal has decided, or is ordered under rule 41.11, to state a case, the tribunal shall, within 14 days after the date of intimation of its decision to the parties, cause the case to be prepared in Form 41.12 and copies of it to be submitted in draft to each party.

(2)

The case shall—

(a)

specify the relevant provision of the enactment under which it is prepared;

(b)

state in numbered paragraphs the facts and the circumstances out of which the case arises, as agreed or found, or as the case may be, the decision of the tribunal and the reasons for the decision; and

(c)

set out the question for answer by the court.

(3)

Within 21 days after the date on which the draft case is submitted under paragraph (1), each party shall—

(a)

return a copy of it to the clerk of the tribunal with a note of any amendments which he or she seeks to have made; and

(b)

intimate such amendments to every other party.

(4)

Within 28 days after the expiry of the period for return of the case under paragraph (3), the tribunal—

(a)

shall adjust and settle the case; and

(b)

may, when so doing, add such further or additional findings-in-fact and such additional questions as it thinks necessary for the disposal of the subject-matter of the case.

(5)

Where the tribunal does not accept any amendment sought by a party, it shall append to the case a note of—

(a)

the terms of the amendment proposed by the party and any statement by that party in support of the proposal; and

(b)

its reasons for rejecting the proposed amendment.

(6)

When the case has been settled by the tribunal, the case shall be authenticated by the clerk of the tribunal who shall send it to the party, or first party, who applied for it.

Intimation of intention to proceed

41.13. (1) The party to whom the case has been sent under rule 41.12(6) or paragraph (3) of this rule shall, within 14 days after the date of receipt of it—

(a)

intimate to every other party a notice stating whether or not he or she intends to proceed with the case; and

(b)

send a copy of the case to every other party.

(2)

Where the party to whom the case has been sent under rule 41.12(6) does not intend to proceed with it, he or she shall, on intimating that fact to every other party under paragraph (1), send the case back to the clerk of the tribunal.

(3)

On receipt of the case sent back under paragraph (2), the clerk of the tribunal shall send it to any other party who had applied for a case.

Lodging of case in court

41.14. (1) The party who applied for the case shall, within the period mentioned in paragraph (2)—

(a)

lodge in the General Department—

(i)

the case; and

(ii)

a process in accordance with rule 4.4 (steps of process) including any productions to be referred to in the appeal;

(b)

on giving written intimation to every other party of the lodging of the case, send four copies of the case to every other party; and

(c)

endorse and sign a certificate on the case that the requirements of rule 4.6 (intimation of steps of process) have been complied with.

(2)

The period referred to in paragraph (1) is—

This article is long: the rest is at the official publication.