Categorisation of serious infringements
(referred to in Article 1)
The following tables contain categories and types of serious infringements against the Union rules in commercial road transport, divided into three categories of seriousness according to their potential to create a risk of fatalities or serious injuries or of distorting competition in the road transport market, or both.
1.
Groups of infringements against Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council(Driving and resting time)
MSI = most serious infringements/VSI = very serious infringement/SI = serious infringement.
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Crew
| Article 5.1 | Not respecting minimum ages for conductors | | | X
Driving periods
| Article 6.1 | Exceed daily driving time of 9h if possibilities to extend to 10h not allowed | 10h ≤ … < 11h | | | X
| 11h ≤ … | | X |
| Exceed daily driving time of 9h by 50 % or more | 13h30 ≤ … | X | |
| Exceed extended daily driving time of 10h if extension allowed | 11h ≤ … < 12h | | | X
| 12h ≤ … | | X |
| Exceed daily driving time of 10h by 50 % or more | 15h ≤ … | X | |
| Article 6.2 | Exceed weekly driving time | 60h ≤ … < 65h | | | X
| 65h ≤ … < 70h | | X |
| Exceed weekly driving time by 25 % or more | 70h ≤ … | X | |
| Article 6.3 | Exceed maximum total driving time during 2 consecutive weeks | 100h ≤ … < 105h | | | X
| 105h ≤ … < 112h30 | | X |
| Exceed maximum total driving time during 2 consecutive weeks by 25 % or more | 112h30≤ … | X | |
Breaks
| Article 7 | Exceed uninterrupted driving time of 4,5 hours before taking the break | 5h ≤ … < 6h | | | X
| 6h ≤ … | | X |
Rest Periods
| Article 8.2 | Insufficient daily rest period of less than 11h if reduced daily rest period not allowed | 8h30 ≤ … < 10h | | | X
| … < 8h30 | | X |
| Insufficient reduced daily rest period of less than 9h if reduce allowed | 7h ≤ … < 8h | | | X
| … < 7h | | X |
| Insufficient split daily rest period of less than 3h + 9h | 3h + [7h ≤ … < 8h] | | | X
| 3h + [… < 7h] | | X |
| Article 8.5 | Insufficient daily rest period of less than 9h for multi-manning | 7h ≤ … < 8h | | | X
| … < 7h | | X |
| Article 8.6 | Insufficient reduced weekly resting period of less than 24 h | 20h ≤ … < 22h | | | X
| … < 20h | | X |
| Insufficient weekly resting period of less than 45 h if reduced weekly resting period not allowed | 36h ≤ … < 42h | | | X
| … < 36h | | X |
28 | Article 8.6 | Exceeding 6 consecutive 24-hour periods following the previous weekly rest period | 3h ≤ … < 12h | | | X
28A. | 12h ≤ … | | X |
28B. | Article 8.6b | No compensation rest for two consecutive reduced weekly rest periods | | | X |
28C. | Article 8.8 | Regular weekly rest period or any weekly rest period of more than 45 hours taken in a vehicle | | | X |
28D. | Article 8.8 | The employer not covering costs for accommodation outside the vehicle | | | | X
…
… | … | … | … | … | …
Work organisation
A32 . | Article 8.8a | Transport undertaking not organising the work of drivers in such a way that the drivers are able to return to the employer’s operational centre, or to return to the drivers’ place of residence | | X |
| Article 10.1 |
Link between wage or payment and one or more of—
distance travelled;
speed of delivery;
amount of goods carried
X |
| Article 10.2 | No or improper organisation of driver's work, no or improper instructions given to driver enabling him to comply with the law | | X |
2.
Groups of infringements against Regulation (EU) No 165/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council(Tachograph)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Installation of tachograph
| Article 3.1, 1za, 1a and 1b and Article 22 | Not having type-approved tachograph installed and used | X | |
Use of tachograph, driver card or record sheet
| Article 23.1 | Using a tachograph not inspected by an approved workshop | | X |
| Article 27 | Driver holding and/or using more than one own driver card | | X |
| Driving with a driver card that has been falsified (considered as driving without driver card) | X | |
| Driving with a driver card of which the driver is not the holder (considered as driving without driver card) | X | |
| Driving with a driver card which has been obtained on the basis of false declarations and/or forged documents (considered as driving without driver card) | X | |
| Article 32.1 | Tachograph not correctly functioning (e.g.: tachograph not properly inspected, calibrated and sealed) | | X |
| Article 32.1 and Article 33.1 | Tachograph improperly used (e.g.: deliberate, voluntary or imposed misuse, lack of instructions on correct use, etc.) | | X |
| Article 32.3 | Having in the vehicle or using a fraudulent device able to modify the records of the tachograph | X | |
| Falsifying, concealing, supressing or destroying data recorded on the record sheets or stored and downloaded from the tachograph and/or the driver card | X | |
| Article 33.2 | Undertaking not keeping record sheets, printouts and downloaded data | | X |
| Recorded and stored data not available for at least a year | | X |
| Article 34.1 | Incorrect use of record sheets/driver card | | X |
| Unauthorised withdrawal of record sheets or driver card which has an impact on the record of relevant data | | X |
| Record sheet or driver card used to cover a period longer than that for which it is intended and data is lost | | X |
| Article 34.2 | Use dirty or damaged record sheets or drivers card and data not legible | | X |
| Article 34.3 | Not using manual input when required to do so | | X |
| Article 34.4 | Not using correct record sheet or driver card not in the correct slot (multi-manning) | | | X
| Article 34.5 | Incorrect use of switch mechanism | | X |
Producing information
A20. | Article 34.5, point (b)(v) | Incorrect use or non-use of the ferry/train sign | | | X
B20. | Article 34.6 | Required information not entered on the record sheet | | X |
C20. | Article 34.7 | Records not showing the symbols of the countries whose borders were crossed by the driver during the daily working period | | | X
D20. | Article 34.7 | Records not showing the symbols of the countries where the driver’s daily working period started and finished | | | X
| Article 36 | Refusing to be checked | | X |
… | … | … | | … |
| Article 36 | Unable to produce manual records and printouts made during the current day and the previous 28 days or 56 days, whichever is applicable | | X |
| Article 36 | Unable to produce a driver card, if the driver holds one | | X |
Malfunctioning
| Article 37.1 and Article 22.1 | Tachograph not repaired by an approved fitter or workshop | | X |
| Article 37.2 | Driver not marking all required information for the periods of time which are no longer recorded while tachograph is unserviceable or malfunctioning | | X |
3.
Groups of infringements against Directive 2002/15/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council(Working time rules)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Maximum weekly working time
| Article 4 | Exceeding maximum weekly working time of 48h if possibilities to extend to 60h already consumed | 56h ≤ … 60h | | | X
| 60h ≤ … | | X |
| Exceeding maximum weekly working time of 60h if no derogation under Article 8 granted | 65 ≤ … < 70h | | | X
| 70h ≤ … | | X |
Breaks
| Article 5.1 | Insufficient obligatory break taken when working time between 6 and 9 hours | 10 < … ≤ 20 min | | | X
| … ≤ 10 min | | X |
| Insufficient obligatory break taken when working time over 9 hours | 20 < … ≤ 30min | | | X
| … ≤ 20 min | | X |
Night work
| Article 7.1 | Daily working time in each 24h when night work performed if no derogation under Article 8 granted | 11h ≤ … < 13h | | | X
| 13h ≤ … | | X |
Records
| Article 9 | Employers falsifying working time records or refusing to provide records to inspection officer | | X |
| Employed/self-employed drivers falsifying records or refusing to provide records to inspection officer | | X |
4.
Groups of infringements against Council Directive 96/53/EC(Weight and dimension rules)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Weights
| Article 1 | Exceed maximum permissible weight for N3 vehicles | 5 % ≤ … < 10 % | | | X
| 10 % ≤ … < 20 % | | X |
| 20 % ≤ … | X | |
| Exceed maximum permissible weight for N2 vehicles | 5 % ≤ … < 15 % | | | X
| 15 % ≤ … < 25 % | | X |
| 25 % ≤ … | X | |
Lengths
| Article 1 | Exceed maximum permissible length | 2 % < … < 20 % | | | X
| 20 % ≤ … | | X |
Width
| Article 1 | Exceed maximum permissible width | 2,65 ≤ … < 3,10 metres | | | X
| 3,10 metres ≤ … | | X |
5.
Groups of infringements against Directive 2014/45/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council(Periodic roadworthiness tests) and Directive 2014/47/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council(Technical roadside inspection)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Roadworthiness
| Article 8 and 10 Directive 2014/45/EU and Article 7.1 of Directive 2014/47/EU | Driving without a valid proof of roadworthiness tests passed, as required by the EU law | X | |
| Article 12.2 of Directive 2014/47/EU | Not keeping a vehicle in a safe and roadworthy condition resulting in a very serious deficiency of the braking system, the steering linkages, the wheels/tires, the suspension or chassis or other equipment that would create such an immediate risk to road safety that it leads to a decision to immobilise the vehicle | X | |
Directive 2014/47/EU on technical roadside inspection of the roadworthiness of commercial vehicles contains in its Annex II a detailed classification of technical deficiencies divided, according to their level of severity, into minor, major and dangerous deficiencies. Article 12.2 of this Directive provides for the following definitions:
minor deficiencies having no significant effect on the safety of the vehicle or impact on the environment, and other minor non-compliances;
major deficiencies that may prejudice the safety of the vehicle or have an impact on the environment or put other road users at risk, or other more significant non-compliances;
dangerous deficiencies constituting a direct and immediate risk to road safety or having an impact on the environment.
The level of infringements against the provisions of the roadworthiness directives shall reflect the classification of deficiencies contained in Annex II of Directive 2014/47/EU, namely: SI = major deficiencies; VSI = dangerous deficiencies; MSI = driving with deficiencies, which creates immediate risk to road safety. Minor deficiencies would be equal to the level of minor infringements.
6.
Groups of infringements against Council Directive 92/6/EEC(Speed limitation devices)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Article 2 and 3 | Speed limitation device not fitted | X | |
| Article 5 | Speed limitation device not satisfying the applicable technical requirements | | X |
| Article 5 | Speed limitation device not fitted by an approved workshop | | | X
| | Having or using a fraudulent device able to falsify data of speed limitation device or having or using a fraudulent speed limitation device | X | |
7.
Groups of infringements against Directive 2003/59/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council(Initial qualification and periodic training of drivers)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
Training and licence
| Article 3 | Carrying goods or passengers without a compulsory initial qualification and/or compulsory periodic training | | X |
| Article 10 and Annex II | Driver unable to present the valid qualification card or the driving licence with the marking, as required by the national law (e.g.: lost, forgotten, damaged, unreadable) | | | X
8.
Groups of infringements against Directive 2006/126/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council(Driving licences requirements)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Articles 1 and 4 of Directive 2006/126/EC | Carrying passengers or goods without holding a valid driving licence | X | |
|
Article 1
Annex I
Using a driving licence which is damaged or unreadable or not in line with common model | | | X
9.
Groups of infringements against Directive 2008/68/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council(Transport of dangerous goods by road)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Annex I, Section I.1 to Directive 2008/68/EC | Transporting dangerous goods that are prohibited for transport | X | |
| Transporting dangerous goods in a prohibited or non-approved means of containment, thus endangering lives or the environment to such extent that it leads to a decision to immobilise the vehicle | X | |
| Transporting dangerous goods without identifying them on the vehicle as dangerous goods, thus endangering lives or the environment to such extent that it leads to a decision to immobilise the vehicle | X | |
| Leakage of dangerous substances | | X |
| Carriage in bulk in a container which is not structurally serviceable | | X |
| Carriage in a vehicle without an appropriate certificate of approval | | X |
| Vehicle no longer complies with the approval standards and presents an immediate danger | | X |
| The rules governing the securing and stowage of the load have not been complied with | | X |
| The rules governing mixed loading of packages have not been complied with | | X |
| The provisions limiting the quantities carried in one transport unit have not been complied with, including permissible degrees of filling tanks or packages; | | X |
| Information relevant to the substance being carried enabling determination of level of seriousness of offence is missing (e.g. UN number, proper shipping name, packing group) | | X |
| Driver does not hold a valid vocational training certificate | | X |
| Fire or an unprotected light is being used | | X |
| The ban on smoking is not being observed. | | X |
| The vehicle is not properly supervised or parked | | | X
| The transport unit comprises more than one trailer/semi-trailer | | | X
| Vehicle no longer complies with the approval standards but does not present an immediate danger | | | X
| The vehicle is not carrying operational fire extinguishers as required | | | X
| The vehicle does not carry the equipment required in the ADR or in the instructions in writing | | | X
| Packages with damaged packaging, IBCs or large packaging or damaged uncleaned empty packaging are being carried | | | X
| Carriage of packaged goods in a container which is not structurally serviceable | | | X
| Tanks/tank containers (including ones that are empty and uncleaned) have not been closed properly | | | X
| Incorrect labelling, marking or placarding on the vehicle and/or containment | | | X
| There are no instructions in writing conforming to the ADR, or the instructions in writing are not relevant to the goods carried | | | X
Commission Directive 2004/112/EC, adapting Council Directive 95/50/EC on uniform procedures for checks on the transport of dangerous goods by road, contains in its Annex II a detailed classification of infringements against the relevant provisions, divided, according to their level of severity, into three risk categories: risk category I, risk category II, risk category III.
The level of infringements against the provisions shall reflect the risk categories provided in Annex II to Directive 2004/112/EC, in such a way that risk category I = VSI (except those infringements which are already defined as MSI in Annex IV to Regulation (EC) No 1071/2009); risk category II = SI. Risk category III is equal to the level of minor infringement.
This table covers only those infringements for which a carrier shall be held fully or partially liable. The level of liability of a carrier for the infringement shall be assessed in accordance with the Member State's national enforcement procedure.
10.
Groups of infringements against Regulation (EC) No 1072/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council(Access to the international road haulage market)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
UK licence for the Community or Community licence
| Article 3 and Article 8.1 | Carrying goods without holding a valid UK licence for the Community or Community licence issued by a Member State (i.e. a UK licence for the Community or Community licence issued by a Member State is non-existent, falsified, withdrawn, expired, etc.) | X | |
| Article 4 | The haulage undertaking or the driver unable to present a valid UK licence for the Community or a valid certified true copy of such a licence to the inspecting officer (i.e.: UK licence for the Community or certified true copy thereof lost, forgotten, damaged, etc.) | | X |
Driver attestation or EU driver attestation
| Article 3 and Article 8.1 | Carrying goods without holding a valid driver attestation or a valid EU driver attestation (i.e. driver attestation or EU driver attestation is non-existent, falsified; withdrawn, expired, etc.) | | X |
| Article 5 | The driver or the haulage undertaking unable to present a valid EU driver attestation or a valid certified true copy of the EU driver attestation to the inspecting officer (i.e. EU driver attestation or certified true copy of the EU driver attestation lost, forgotten, damaged, etc.) | | | X
Cabotage
| Article 9 | Carrying out a cabotage operation not in compliance with the laws, regulations and administrative provisions in force in the United Kingdom | | X |
11.
Groups of infringements against Regulation (EC) No 1073/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council(Access to the market for coach and bus services)
…
12.
Groups of infringements against Council Regulation (EC) No 1/2005(Animal transport)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENTS | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Annex I, Chapter II, | Partitions are not strong enough to withstand the weight of animals | | X |
| Annex I, Chapter III | Using loading or unloading ramps that has slippery surfaces, that lack lateral protections or that are too steep | | | X
| Using lifting platforms or upper floors that do not have safety barriers preventing animals from falling or escaping during loading and unloading operations | | | X
| Article 7 | Means of transport not approved for long journeys, or not approved for the type of animals being transported. | | | X
| Article 4, 5 and 6 | Transporting without valid required documentation, journey log or transporter authorisation or certificate of competence | | | X
13.
Infringement against Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council (law applicable to contractual obligations)
No | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 | Violation of the law applicable to contractual obligations | | X |
14.
Groups of infringements against obligations under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement between the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, of the one part, and the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community, of the other part entered into on 30th December 2020
No. | LEGAL BASIS | TYPE OF INFRINGEMENT | LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS
MSI | VSI | SI
| Article 462, paragraphs 3 to 7 | Failure to comply with the limitations on the number of journeys | | X |
| Article 463(3) | The haulage undertaking or the driver unable to present a valid Community licence or a valid certified true copy of such a licence to the inspecting officer (i.e. Community licence or certified true copy thereof lost, forgotten, damaged, etc.) | | X |
Section 2 of Part A of Annex 31
| Article 6(1), point (a) | Incomplete information on the posting declaration | | | X
| Article 6(1), point (b) | Failure to submit a posting declaration to the country to which the driver is posted no later than the commencement of the posting | | X |
| Article 6(1), point (b) | Falsified posting declaration for drivers | | X |
| Article 6(1), point (b) | Impossibility of the driver to present a valid posting declaration | | X |
| Article 6(1), point (b) | Failure to put at the disposal of the driver a valid posting declaration | | X |
| Article 6(1), second subparagraph | Failure to submit the requested documents to the host country within eight weeks from the date of the request | | X |
| Article 6(4) | Failure of the operator to keep the posting declaration up to date in the public interface connected to IMI | | | X