Technical Committee 52 of the European Committee for Standardisation (CEN) (‘CEN/TC 52’) reacted to the formal objection lodged by Germany by requesting more details regarding the accident, in particular concerning the specific risk and the model toy involved in the accident. CEN/TC 52 also inquired whether the rod depicted in the formal objection was a 5 mm or 12 mm diameter rod, arguing that the toy involved in the accident was not in compliance with the existing (published) standard, namely its clause 4.15.1.6 c) – which is the general requirement for finger entrapment for ride-on toys. CEN/TC 52’s assessment was based on the fact that one of the photos presented in the formal objection showed the entry of the smaller test rod into some gaps between the wheel and the frame, and it looked as if those same gaps would not accept the breadth of the probes or rods as specified in the respective test method of the existing standard, thus representing a non-compliance. According to that assessment, compliance with the existing standard may have prevented the injury or at least reduced its severity. CEN/TC 52, however, also drew the attention to the fact that work was already being carried out in its relevant working group to address the shortcomings identified by the German authorities in the formal objection, by revising the standards in question: the draft revised version provides, in clause 4.15, for new requirements for ride-on toys covering the risks of crushing and shearing of the finger.
Recital 8, Decision_act (EU) 2025/1785
In forcesince 9 Sep 2025