99 6. LEVEL OF MEASURES › 6.1. Injury margin, Regulation (EU) 2024/3014

In forcesince 13 Dec 2024

STL Group claimed that the provisional dumping margins and injury margins demonstrated that something was wrong with the calculation of the dumping margin of the STL Group because: (i) while the export prices of the STL Group were by far the highest, with export prices that are reportedly over 45 % higher than some other exporting producers (a lower injury margin obviously indicating a higher export price); and (ii) while the STL Group was the only fully integrated exporting producer in India, manufacturing the product under investigation from the production of preformed glass, thereby the most cost-efficient producer, the result was still that STL Group received the highest dumping margin. Furthermore, the STL Group claimed that this result was mathematically impossible unless the domestic sales prices of the STL Group were somehow more than 45 % higher than those of some other producers, but this was definitely not the case since the domestic prices of all Indian producers on the Indian home market were similar or at least fluctuate within a range that is much narrower than 45 %. This paradox of having both the highest export prices and the highest dumping margin, therefore, demonstrated that the Commission’s adjustments to the export price and to the costs of STL Group have created a situation that is legally untenable and mathematically impossible.