48 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Export price, Regulation (EU) 2024/3014

In forcesince 13 Dec 2024

The Commission considered that it was not possible to use the profit margins of related parties, which would run contrary to the provisions of Article 2(9) of the basic Regulation, as it is considered to be affected by the association. The Commission also notes that a profit margin of 5 % is only applied in exceptional circumstances (i.e. there is no other information available). This is not the case here, where the information available to the Commission clearly shows that a 5 % profit margin in this case is not appropriate. Finally, the Commission examined the report submitted by the STL Group and found that only four of the listed companies had fibre optics in their catalogue of products. In addition, these companies were not specialised in the fibre optic business but rather were wholesalers of various copper power cables, electrical materials and other industrial tools. Moreover, publicly available financial statements of these companies did not provide either the profitability of each segment or the weight of each segment in the total turnover. Finally, there is no indication of whether these companies actually produced or merely imported OFC for resale in the EU market. Therefore, the unrelated importer profit margin established in the Chinese investigation remained the most suitable alternative as the profit related to an unrelated importer, concerned the OFC business and was verified. Finally, and most notably, no evidence suggesting that a profit margin, which was considered to be ‘reasonable’ for imports from China, would be unreasonable for imports from India were presented by any interested party. Therefore, the options proposed by the STL Group were rejected.