Art. 38 Regulation (EU) 2024/2027

Independence and impartiality

In forcesince 26 Jul 2024
1.

A verifier shall be independent from a company and impartial in carrying out its verification activities.

2.

To ensure independence and impartiality, the verifier and any part of the same legal entity shall not be a company, the owner of a company or owned by it, nor shall the verifier have relations with the company that could affect its independence and impartiality.

3.

Verifiers shall be organised in such a way as to safeguard their objectivity, independence and impartiality. The relevant requirements laid down in the harmonised standard referred to in Article 35(2) shall apply.

4.

Verifiers shall not carry out verification activities for a company that poses an unacceptable risk to their impartiality or in respect of which they have a conflict of interest. The verifier shall not use personnel or contracted persons in the assessment of a monitoring plan or in the verification of a FuelEU report and partial FuelEU report that could have an actual or potential conflict of interest. The verifier shall also ensure that the activities of personnel or organisations do not affect the confidentiality, objectivity, independence and impartiality of the verification. For that purpose, the verifier shall monitor the risks to impartiality and take appropriate action to address those risks.

5.

A conflict of interest for a verifier in its relations with a company shall be deemed to have arisen in particular in either of the following cases:

(a)

where the relationship between the verifier and the company is based on common ownership, common governance, common management or personnel, shared resources, common finances and common contracts or common marketing;

(b)

where the company has received consulting services referred to in paragraph 7, point (a), or technical assistance referred to in paragraph 7, point (b), from a consultancy body, technical assistance body or another organisation having relations with the verifier and threatening the impartiality of the verifier.

6.

For the purposes of paragraph 5, point (b), the verifier’s impartiality shall be deemed compromised where the relations between the verifier and the consultancy body, technical assistance body or the other organisation is based on common ownership, common governance, common management or personnel, shared resources, common finances, common contracts or common marketing and common payment of sales commission or other inducement for the referral of new clients.

7.

An unacceptable risk to the impartiality or a conflict of interest shall be deemed to have arisen where a verifier, or any part of the same legal entity, provides a company with the following:

(a)

consulting services to develop part of the monitoring and reporting process described in the monitoring plan, including the development of the monitoring methodology, the drafting of the FuelEU report or the partial FuelEU report and the drafting of the monitoring plan;

(b)

technical assistance to develop or maintain the system for monitoring and reporting emissions or other relevant information pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2023/1805.

8.

Verifiers shall not outsource the independent review or the issuance of the verification report.

9.

Where verifiers outsource other verification activities, sub-contracted companies shall meet the relevant requirements laid down in the harmonised standard referred to in Article 35(2).

10.

However, contracting individuals to carry out verification activities shall not constitute outsourcing for the purposes of paragraph 9 where the verifier, when contracting those individuals, takes full responsibility for the verification activities performed by contracted personnel.

11.

When contracting individuals for carrying out verification activities the verifier shall require those individuals to sign a written agreement that they comply with the procedures of the verifier and that there is no conflict of interest in carrying out those verification activities.

12.

Verifiers shall establish, document, implement and maintain a process to ensure their continuous impartiality and independence, and that of the parts of the same legal entity, of other organisations referred to in paragraph 6, and of all personnel and contracted individuals involved in the verification. That process shall include a mechanism to safeguard the impartiality and independence of the verifier and shall meet the relevant requirements laid down in the harmonised standard referred to in Article 35.

13.

When verifying a company which has already verified in previous years, the verifier shall consider the risk to impartiality and take the necessary measures to reduce the risk of impartiality.