59 2. PRODUCT UNDER INVESTIGATION, PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT › 2.4. Claims regarding product scope, Regulation (EU) 2024/1943

In forcesince 11 Jul 2024

HFCL and Birla agreed with Aksh that optical fibres not individually sheathed should be excluded from the scope of this investigation. They relied in support of their interpretation of what constitutes ‘an individual sheath’ on a judgment of 21 November 2017 of the Indian Appellate Tribunal in the case Commissioner of Customs (Import) Mumbai vs Vodafone Essar Gujarat Ltd. [Reproduced in Annex to the non-confidential version of HFCL’s submission of 2 January 2024 and in Annex 2 to the non-confidential version of Birla’s submission of 2 January 2024.], which concerned the customs classification of certain OFC imported in India. The Indian authority considered the definition of the term ‘individually sheathed’ and found that a ‘“sheath” is something different from a “coating”’.