177 4. REQUESTS FOR EXEMPTION › 4.3. Vietnam › 4.3.2. Posco VST Co., Ltd., Regulation (EU) 2024/1268

In forcesince 6 May 2024

Following disclosure, EUROFER concluded from recital (176) that the Commission assessed the criteria of article 13(2)(b) of the basic AD regulation (applied by analogy in this subsidy investigation), and specifically the 60 % rule laid therein, at the level of the producer rather than the product. EUROFER considered that the adoption of such approach was incompatible with the stated purpose and objective of the anti-circumvention provision. Although the Commission has used this approach in previous cases, EUROFER claimed that such approach is not relevant nor appropriate in the case at hand, that it leads to absurd and nonsensical results and that it would go against the very purpose of the anti-circumvention provision by preventing capturing the largest circumventing volumes. According to EUROFER, the Commission should base its interpretation of the assembly/completion operations test on adherence to the requirements of the basic AD Regulation and case law, and not its prior practice.