Recital 4, Decision_act (EU) 2024/2712

In forcesince 23 Oct 2024

The second point of disagreement raised by Germany concerns the dermal absorption value used by France for the assessment of exposure of livestock. Germany considers that the default dermal absorption value for water-based dilutions of 50 % established in the EFSA guidance on dermal absorption [EFSA Guidance on dermal absorption of 24 May 2017 https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.2903/j.efsa.2017.4873.] only applies to human skin and is not applicable by analogy to animals. As there is no data on livestock dermal absorption, France believes that the dermal absorption value of 50 % should be used for livestock as it represents the worst case scenario, and points out that the dermal absorption value of 50 % was used for the evaluation of the application for approval of chlorocresol. To refine the assessment on exposure of livestock, Germany proposed the application of a default transfer coefficient for dislodgeable residues transferred from treated surfaces as established in the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) Human Health Exposure Methodology [ECHA Guidance for Human Health Risk Assessment, Volume III Human Health, Part B Risk Assessment, Draft Version 2.0, May 2015. https://echa.europa.eu/documents/10162/23047722/bpr_vol_iii_partb_draft_chapter3_ca_en.pdf/04f7ba38-c55e-48a7-a1f3-e9ef0024cc23.], and the application of empirical transfer factors from a study by Leeman et al. (2007), as established in the European Medicines Agency guideline on risk characterisation and assessment of maximum residue limits for biocides [EMA/CVMP/90250/2010.] to estimate the maximum transfer of an external oral dose to livestock edible tissues. France considers that even considering those two refinement factors, the estimation of residues in edible tissues exceeds the MRL of 0,01 mg/kg established for chlorocresol in accordance with Article 18(1), point (b), of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005.