ANNEX I FINAL ORGANIC MATERIAL, Decision_act (EU) 2024/368

In forcesince 23 Jan 2024

The procedure for testing and accepting final organic materials as used in a product includes the following steps:

Step 1 – Identification of relevant substances and relevant other parameters depending on:

1.

Categorisation of products or components into risk groups and corresponding testing requirements

2.

Formulation review

Step 2 – Performance of tests

1.

Migration test for

(a)

Total Organic Carbon (TOC)

(b)

Relevant substances

(c)

Unexpected substances

2.

Modelling of migration of relevant substances

3.

Migration test for

(a)

Odour and flavour

(b)

Colour and turbidity

4.

Testing for Enhancement of Microbial Growth (EMG)

5.

Testing residual content of substances

Step 3 – Compliance with pass/fail criteria

For each product or component of an assembled product, a product group and a corresponding conversion factor (CF) shall be determined in accordance with Table 5. Based on the determined CF, the product or component is categorised in a risk group (RG) in accordance with Table 1.

The categorisation in a RG determines the corresponding testing requirements including the relevant substances and relevant other parameters. The applicable testing procedure of final organic materials results from the use of these materials in products or components of assembled products.

Minor components are considered to be components categorised in risk group 3 or 4 (RG3 or RG4) and for which reduced testing requirements, as set out in Table 1, may apply in comparison with the testing requirements for the risk group 1 or 2 (RG1 or RG2).

For an assembled product, the components shall be determined. For each component in an assembled product, a product group shall be determined. If an assembled product consists of components made of the same main polymer, then the surface fraction of these components shall be cumulatively added for the determination of the product group in accordance with Table 5.

Products or components made of multilayer materials are considered as one final material consisting of several layers.

The testing shall be performed on the final materials as used in products in contact with water intended for human consumption.

The specification in Table 1 for testing ‘on product or component’ means that the individual product or component of an assembled product shall be used for the performance of the testing.

The specification in Table 1 for testing on ‘test piece of the formulation’ means that a representative test piece of the final material as used in a product or component can be considered for the testing. In this case it is not required that the individual product or component is tested.

[Threshold odour number] [Threshold flavour number]

Risk group | CF in d/dm | Formu-lation review | Relevant substances | Screening for unexpected substances | TOC | TON, TFN, colour, turbidity | EMG

RG1 | ≥ 4 | Yes | Yes, on product | Yes, on product | Yes, on product | Yes, on product | Yes, on product for pipes with CF >10 d/dm or test piece of the formulation

RG2 | ≥ 0,4 and < 4 | Yes | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product or component | Yes, on (assembled) product or component | Yes, on component or test piece of the formulation

RG3 |

≥ 0,04 and

< 0,4

Yes | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on component or test piece of the formulation

RG4 | < 0,04 | No | No | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on (assembled) product, component or test piece of the formulation | Yes, on component or test piece of the formulation

A formulation review is required in accordance with the requirements in Table 1.

For a formulation review of a final organic material the following information is required:

(a)

list of all starting substances (including their impurities and other specifications) used to produce the final organic material including all monomers, additives, aids to polymerisation, polymer production aids, pigments, colorants and fillers;

(b)

the respective percentage by mass (m/m %) of all starting substances and substances used to produce the final material, adding up to 100 %.

(c)

any other information considered relevant for the assessment of the formulation of the final organic material.

The cut-off value, below which details of the formulation (i.e. the chemical composition of starting substances or impurities) are not required, expressed as mass percentage in the formulation is:

(a)

for one substance: 0,02 % for RG1, 0,05 % for RG2 and 0,1 % for RG3 materials; and

(b)

for the sum of all such substances: 0,1 % for RG1, 0,2 % for RG2 and 0,5 % for RG3.

In case of multilayer products with a total barrier, only the layers between the barrier and the surface in contact with drinking water shall be considered. The formulation shall be specified for each layer to be considered.

The formulation shall be evaluated and compared with the accepted starting substances of the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 [Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 of 23 January 2024 laying down rules for the application of Directive (EU) 2020/2184 of the European Parliament and of the Council by establishing the European positive lists of starting substances, compositions and constituents authorised for use in the manufacture of materials or products that come into contact with water intended for human consumption (OJ L, 2024/367, 2024.04.23, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2024/367/oj).]. One of the objectives of the evaluation is to define the relevant substances, which shall be analysed in the migration water.

The relevant substances are:

(a)

Starting substances used in the formulation, listed in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 and for which an MTCtap applies;

(b)

Substances like impurities, degradation or reaction products specified in the condition of use of the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 used in the formulation;

(c)

All substances set out in Table 4 of Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 of starting substances for organic materials if stabilizers with alkylphenol structural moieties are used;

(d)

Starting substances used in the formulation, their impurities, degradation and reaction products not listed in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367, but accepted under section 2.2.3 (b) of this Annex;

(e)

Aluminium, ammonium, barium, cobalt, copper, europium, gadolinium, iron, lanthanum, lithium, manganese, terbium and/or zinc, if the respective salts of authorised acids, phenols or alcohols, authorised in accordance with note 2. ‘Scope of an authorisation’, point ii. of the Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 are used;

(f)

Starting substances of polymeric substances authorised in accordance with note 2. ‘Scope of an authorisation’, point iii. of the Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 for which an MTCtap applies;

(g)

Starting substances of pre-polymers and natural or synthetic polymers authorised in accordance with note 2. ‘Scope of an authorisation’, point v. of the Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 for which an MTCtap applies;

(h)

Antimony, arsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, lead, mercury, selenium if pigments or colorants are used in the formulation not complying with the purity requirements in accordance with section 4.6 of this Annex or if the purity testing was not performed;

(i)

Primary aromatic amines (PAA) if organic pigments or colorants are used in the formulation not complying with the purity requirements in accordance with section 4.6 of this Annex or if the purity testing was not performed;

(j)

Antimony, arsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, lead, mercury, selenium if fillers are used in the formulation not complying with the purity requirements according to section 4.6 of this Annex or if the purity testing was not performed;

(k)

In case additional material-specific criteria apply (see section 2.2.4): all substances or group of substances for which an MTCtap has been set;

(l)

In case of migration test with chlorinated test water: haloacetic acids (HAAs) and trihalomethanes total, as defined in part B of Annex I – to Directive (EU) 2020/2184.

For multilayer materials, the relevant substances shall be determined for each layer between the total barrier and the drinking water individually.

Organic materials shall only be made of :

(a)

starting substances listed in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367; or

(b)

starting substances for which no migration of the substance, its impurities and/or its reaction and degradation products into drinking water occurs at levels exceeding 0,1 μg/l at the consumer’s tap. This only applies to substances that do not belong to either one of the following categories:

(1)

substances classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic, toxic for reproduction category 1A or 1B, endocrine disrupters (ED) for human health category 1, persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic substances (PBT) or very persistent and very bioaccumulative substances (vPvB) in accordance with Regulation No. 1272/2008 (CLP); or being included in the candidate list as substances of very high concern (SVHC) under Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH) for the ED, PBT or vPvB properties;

(2)

substances intentionally added in nanoform;

(3)

monomers of the main polymers in the material.

The relevant notes of the Annex I to Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 establishing the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials shall be considered in the acceptance of starting substances.

For polyamide or polyurethane resin coatings, requirements on the release of primary aromatic amines (PAA) apply, as specified in Table 2.

Requirements for rubbers are listed in Table 3.

Requirements for organic materials other than rubbers made of starting substances bearing N-functionalities, such as aminic, amidic or quaternary, when tested with chlorinated test water are listed in Table 4.

[Method should be improved to have a Limit f Detection (LOD) of 0,1 μg/l.]

Parameter | Restriction

Sum of Primary Aromatic Amines (PAA) | MTC tap = N.D. (LOD = 0,1 μg/l)

[Method should be improved to have a Limit Of Detection (LOD) of 0,1 μg/l.] [sum of dibutylamine (CAS 111-92-2), diethylamine (CAS 109-89-7), dimethylamine (CAS 124-40-3), dicyclohexylamine (CAS 101-83-7), cyclohexylethylamine (CAS 5459-93-8), diphenylamine (CAS 122-39-4), dibenzylamine (CAS 103-49-1), benzyl-N-methylamine (CAS 103-67-3), benzylidenebenzylamine (CAS,780-25-6) N-methylaniline (CAS 100-61-8), N-ethylaniline (CAS 103-69-5), N-butylaniline (CAS 1126-78-9)] [sum of N-Nitroso-di-n-butylamine (CAS 924-16-3), N-Nitroso-diethanolamine (CAS 1116-54-7), N-Nitroso-diethylamine (CAS 55-18-5), N-Nitroso-diisopropylamine (CAS 601-77-4), N-Nitroso-dimethylamine (CAS 62-75-9), N-Nitroso-di-n-propylamine (CAS 621-64-7), N-Nitroso-ethyl phenylamine (CAS 612-64-6), N-Nitroso-methyl ethylamine (CAS 10595-95-6) N-Nitroso-methyl phenylamine (CAS 614-00-6), N-Nitroso-morpholine (CAS 59-89-2), N-Nitroso-piperidine (CAS 100-75-4), N-Nitroso-pyrrolidine (CAS 930-55-2)]

Parameter | Restriction

Sum of Primary Aromatic Amines (PAA) (a.o. aniline, o-toluidine) | MTC tap = N.D. (LOD = 0,1 μg/l)

Sum of secondary amines | MTC tap = 250 μg/l

Sum of N-nitrosamines | MTC tap = N.D. (LOD = 0,1 μg/l)

[sum of N-Nitroso-di-n-butylamine (CAS 924-16-3), N-Nitroso-diethanolamine (CAS 1116-54-7), N-Nitroso-diethylamine (CAS 55-18-5), N-Nitroso-diisopropylamine (CAS 601-77-4), N-Nitroso-dimethylamine (CAS 62-75-9), N-Nitroso-di-n-propylamine (CAS 621-64-7), N-Nitroso-ethyl phenylamine (CAS 612-64-6), N-Nitroso-methyl ethylamine (CAS 10595-95-6) N-Nitroso-methyl phenylamine (CAS 614-00-6), N-Nitroso-morpholine (CAS 59-89-2), N-Nitroso-piperidine (CAS 100-75-4), N-Nitroso-pyrrolidine (CAS 930-55-2)]

Parameter | Restriction

Sum of N-nitrosamines | MTC tap = N.D. (LOD = 0,1 μg/l)

For testing the release of relevant substances, unexpected substances and TOC, the following standards shall be used to obtain the migration waters:

(a)

For factory-made products: EN 12873-1:2014;

(b)

For site-applied materials: EN 12873-2:2021.

For testing odour and flavour, colour and turbidity, standard EN 1420:2016 shall be used to obtain the migration waters.

The mentioned EN standards leave options for testing. The following provisions in sections 3.1.2, 3.1.3, 3.1.4 and 3.1.5 substantiate these standards.

For a product or a component of which the size does not allow the practical application of the testing, a representative test piece for the testing shall be provided.

Special attention shall be given to the production of the test piece.

All products shall be tested at 23 °C ± 2 °C (cold water test condition).

Additionally, products that are normally used for warm or hot applications shall be tested at 60 °C ± 2 °C or 85 °C ± 2 °C, respectively. For this purpose, warm water corresponds to normal operating temperatures between 30 °C and 70 °C and hot water corresponds to operating temperatures exceeding 70 °C.

Multilayer products shall always be tested at 60 °C ± 2 °C or 85 °C ± 2 °C additionally, even when not used at these temperatures.

Cold water test (23 °C ± 2 °C) shall be performed with chlorinated and non-chlorinated test water.

In case a warm or a hot water test is required, this test shall only be performed with non-chlorinated test water.

For cold water tests the migration samples of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd migration period according to standards shall be analysed. The compliance with the pass/fail criteria shall be assessed at the 3rd migration period (10th day of testing). If the pass/fail criteria set out in sections 4.2 and 4.3 are not met at the 3rd migration period the testing can be extended and the 5th, 7th and 9th period shall be analysed additionally. In this case the pass/fail criteria shall be assessed at the 9th migration period (31st day of testing).

For warm or hot water tests the migration samples of the 1st, 6th and 7th migration period shall be analysed. The compliance with the pass/fail criteria shall be assessed at the 7th migration period (10th day). If the pass/ fail criteria set out in sections 4.2 and 4.3 are not met at the 7th migration period the testing can be extended and the 12th, 17th and 22nd period shall be analysed additionally. In this case the pass/fail criteria shall be assessed at the 22nd migration period (31st day).

For multilayer products an extended warm or hot water migration test is always required to ensure that substances originating from different layers appear in the migration water. To ensure sufficient substance diffusion and equilibration across layer boundaries, it is required that the multilayer product has undergone a storage period at room temperature for at least 30 days.

The relevant substances defined in section 2.2.2 shall be analysed in the migration waters (see section 3.1.5).

The methods for analysis of relevant substances in migration waters shall be validated and documented in accordance with EN ISO/IEC 17025:2017 or other equivalent standards accepted at international level.

Unexpected substances are only determined in the migration waters of the cold water test.

For the identification and semi-quantitative analysis of unexpected substances a GC-MS screening shall be conducted according to EN 15768:2015.

The relevant other parameters shall be analysed in the migration waters according to the following standards:

(a)

Total Organic Carbon (TOC) shall be determined according to EN 1484:1997 as non-purgeable organic carbon;

(b)

Odour shall be determined as Threshold Odour Number (TON) according to EN 1420:2016 and EN 1622:2006;

(c)

Flavour shall be determined as Threshold Flavour Number (TFN) according to EN 1420:2016 and EN 1622:2006;

(d)

Colour shall be determined according to EN ISO 7887:2011 – method C;

(e)

Turbidity shall be determined according to EN ISO 7027-1:2016 - nephelometry.

Where generally recognised diffusion models exist on the basis of experimental data, mathematical modelling for estimation of migration levels may be used as alternative to the migration testing of relevant substances for certain types of final organic materials.

If these recognised diffusion models predict that the migration of the substance complies with the maximum tolerable concentration at the tap (MTCtap), migration testing for these substances is not necessary. For the assessment of some parameters and for modelling, the content of the respective substances in the final material shall be determined.

If compliance is not shown by using the models, migration testing shall be performed.

The following mathematical modelling approaches may be used:

(a)

Migration modelling according to CEN/TR 16364:2012 or other equivalent standards accepted at international level, simulating a migration test according to the EN 12873-1:2014 and EN 12873-2:2021;

(b)

Full transfer calculation, simulating full transfer of substances from the product into the migration water.

For the EMG testing, standard EN 16421:2015 – method 1 or 2 shall be used.

For starting substances with a maximum quantity (QM or QMA) restriction set out in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials of Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367, its residual content in the product shall be analysed.

Starting substances of the formulation listed in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials set out in Annex I of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367.

(a)

shall be used according to the technical function specified in the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials;

(b)

shall be used in compliance with conditions of use established under the European positive list of starting substances for organic materials.

In accordance with the migration standards EN 12873-1:2014 and EN 12873-2:2021, the test results are expressed as migration rates (M) in μg/(dm2.d). These results shall be converted to estimate the concentrations at the tap (Ctap), defined as Ctap = M * CF, where CF is the corresponding conversion factor in d/dm.

The conversion factors for the different product groups are listed in Table 5 to this Annex.

[If from a series of different diameter pipes made from the same pre-product under the same manufacturing process (a so-called product family) the smallest diameter pipe is assessed and approved, then the whole series of different diameter pipes is allowed to be used for all application areas within the product group without further testing.]

(2,3,4) Components (sum of components made of same main polymer or same composition) of assembled products with a wetted surface fraction

[≥ 10 % of the assembled product] [< 10 % of the assembled product] [< 1 % of the assembled product]

Product group | CF (in d/dm)

A | Pipes and pipe linings |

1 | ID < 80 mm (domestic installations, buildings) | 20

2 | 80 mm ≤ ID < 300 mm (service piping) | 10

3 | ID ≥ 300 mm (mains piping) | 5

B | Fittings, ancillaries |

1 | ID < 80 mm (domestic installations, buildings) | 2

2 | 80 mm ≤ ID < 300 mm (service piping) | 1

3 | ID ≥ 300 mm (mains piping) | 0,5

C | Components of fittings, ancillaries |

1 | ID < 80 mm (domestic installations, buildings) | 0,2

2 | 80 mm ≤ ID < 300 mm (service piping) | 0,1

3 | ID ≥ 300 mm (mains piping) | 0,05

D | Small Components of fittings, ancillaries |

1 | ID < 80 mm (domestic installations, buildings) | 0,02

2 | 80 mm ≤ ID < 300 mm (service piping) | 0,01

3 | ID ≥ 300 mm (mains piping) | 0,005

E | Storage systems (reservoirs) |

1 | In domestic installations, buildings, water volume < 10 l | 4

2 | In domestic installations, buildings, water volume ≥ 10 l | 2

3 | In water supply | 1

F | Components of storage systems |

1 | In domestic installations, buildings, water volume < 10 l | 0,4

2 | In domestic installations, buildings; water volume ≥ 10 l | 0,2

3 | In water supply | 0,1

G | Small Components storage systems |

1 | In domestic installations, buildings; water volume < 10 l | 0,04

2 | In domestic installations, buildings; water volume ≥ 10 l | 0,02

3 | In water supply | 0,01

The following requirements shall apply to the cold water migration test:

(a)

Ctap ≤ MTCtap for the 3rd migration period (10th day of testing) or, in case extended testing is needed, at the 9th migration period (31st day of testing);

(b)

there shall be no increasing trend of Ctap in time.

The following requirements shall apply to the warm/hot water migration test:

(a)

Ctap ≤ MTCtap for the 7th migration period (10th day of testing) or, in case extended testing is needed, at the 22nd migration period (31st day of testing);

(b)

there shall be no increasing trend of Ctap in time.

The measured substance concentrations in the migration water from the successive migration periods shall be used to assess the trend. However, if Ctap in the relevant migration period is below 1/10 of MTCtap, no trend analysis is required.

For ions, the MTCtap,organics of Table 1 in Annex V to Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 shall apply.

The following requirement shall apply to the cold water migration test:

(a)

Ctap ≤ MTCtap for the 3rd migration period (10th day of testing) or, in case extended testing is needed, at the 9th migration period (31st day of testing).

The MTCtap for the unexpected substances are set out in Table 6.

[Based on the response of the closest internal standard.]

Parameter | MTCtap

Identified substances with a known MTCtap | MTCtap of the substance

Identified substance without a known MTCtap | 1,0 μg/l

Unidentified substances |

1,0 μg/l per unidentified substance 1

5,0 μg/l for the sum of the unidentified substances

The following requirements shall apply to the cold water migration test:

This article is long: the rest is at the official publication.