46 3. DUMPING › 3.1. Morocco › 3.1.1. Cooperation of exporting producers, Regulation (EU) 2022/1221

In forcesince 14 Jul 2022

The company replied to the Commission’s letter on 12 May 2022. In its reply the company explained that it had recorded its sales in the sales listings in accordance with its accounting principles. The company therefore maintained, in contrast to statements made during the RCC and the on-spot verification visit, that the original sales listings, the total values of which could be reconciled with the company’s SAP accounting system, were complete and accurate, contained no errors and required no revisions. In fact, the revisions that the company had done post RCC, were allegedly only provided to the Commission to show CITIC’s full cooperation in the investigation. The company therefore stated that the Commission should use the original non-revised version of the sales listings. In the alternative, the company stated that the Commission could use the revised sales listings, provided with the letter, since the deficiencies were allegedly not such as to cause undue difficulty in arriving at a reasonably accurate finding. These sales listings were similar to those provided during the on-spot verification, to which previously missing data was added, some errors were corrected and additional explanations were provided. However, several errors still remained, for a number of transactions the actual received amount was still not provided and the Commission was not in the position to cross-check or verify the revised sales listings provided with the company’s reply to the Article 18 letter. The company also stated that, in case the Commission would insist on the application of Article 18 of the basic Regulation, it should use CITIC’s financial statements as partial facts available.