The protocol for the assessment of the resistance of a variety shall include the following steps.
A minimum of 40 tubers or eye plugs per variety of the specified plant shall be tested. They shall be divided into two groups (replicates).
The test shall generally last for 2 years. Only in case that a variety shows to be extremely susceptible to a pathotype of the specified pest, the length of the test may be reduced to 1 year.
Before a testing season starts, the inoculum shall be tested for purity, using the methods described in Annex I.
A positive control, in the form of a variety of the specified plant, which is extremely susceptible to the pathotype of the specified pest to be tested, shall always be included in the test.
One of the following testing methods shall be used:
the Glynne-Lemmerzahl method (Glynne 1925, Lemmerzahl 1930, Noble & Glynne 1970);
the Spieckermann method (Spieckermann & Kothoff 1924); or
the SASA (Science and Advice for Scottish Agriculture) method, consisting of all of the following steps:
tuber preparation:
Tubers shall be removed from the cold store around 10 days before intended inoculation, washed gently, dried and stored in the dark at room temperature to induce sprouting.
A highly susceptible variety (‘Morene’ or a variety with comparable susceptibility) shall be included in each inoculation to serve as positive control;
germination of resting spores:
Conditions to induce germination of resting spores shall be set up 21 days prior to inoculation.
Approximately 10 mg of extracted spores shall be sprinkled onto the surface of 10 ml of sterile distilled water in small plastic Petri dishes and incubated in the dark at 20 °C until germination.
The content of each Petri dish shall be diluted with another 10 ml of sterile distilled water for the inoculation;
inoculation and incubation of sprouts:
When the sprouts reach 1 mm in length, they shall be ringed with melted Vaseline. The Vaseline ring shall be unbroken to hold the spore suspension without leaking and high enough for the suspension to cover the sprout.
A single sprout or a single cluster of sprouts shall be ringed on each tuber.
The tubers shall be placed in plastic boxes, lined with damp tissue paper with the ringed sprouts facing upwards.
The Vaseline rings shall be filled with spore suspension, using a pipette or a squeeze bottle until the sprout is completely submerged.
The plastic boxes shall be covered with lids and incubated for 4 days at 10 °C in the dark, after which the Vaseline rings shall be removed and the boxes shall be placed open in a glasshouse at 15–18 °C under periodic misting (3 times per day for 30 min).
In cases where the infection failed, for example because the sprout rotted or failed to develop, the tuber may be retested using another sprout;
assessment:
Sprouts shall be examined for infection 28 days after the inoculation, using a stereo microscope with 10–15x magnification and a light microscope.
Reactions of score 4 or 5, as set out in the table, shall be observed on the positive control on at least 80 % of tubers. At least one tuber shall show a score of 5.
All tubers shall be assessed and given a resistance ranking score from 1 to 5, as set out in the table.
Each tested variety shall be placed in a resistance group (‘highly resistant’, ‘resistant’, ‘slightly susceptible’, or ‘extremely susceptible’), according to the range of scores observed within the respective population of individual tubers or eye plugs tested:
a variety shall be considered ‘highly resistant’, if all tubers in all replicates have a score of 1;
a variety shall be considered ‘resistant’, if all tubers in all replicates have a score between 1 and 3;
a variety shall be considered ‘slightly susceptible’, if one or more tubers score 4 (if only one tuber scores 4, the test may be repeated, in order to exclude impurity in the variety lot);
a variety shall be considered ‘extremely susceptible’, if at least one tuber in one replicate scores 5.
Standard score | Group of resistance | Resistance description | Description
1 | R1 | Extremely resistant | Early defence necrosis; no visible sorus formation.
2 | R1 | Resistant | Late defence necrosis; sorus formation partially visible, sori immature or necrotic before maturity.
3 | R2 | Weakly resistant |
Very late defence necrosis; single ripe sori or sorus fields developed, but completely surrounded by necrosis; up to five non-necrotic summer sori permitted, clear necrosis in other zones of the same tuber piece. No formation of warts or resting spores.
To decide between groups 3 and 4, it may be necessary to prepare thin slides of infected tissue: if there are no resting spores, the score shall be 3.
4 | S1 | Slightly susceptible |
Scattered infections; sori or sorus fields non-necrotic, few in number; late necrosis can be present on other infection sites on the sprout; the sprout can be slightly malformed (thickened). Resting (winter) sporangia are present.
To decide between group 3 and 4, it may be necessary to prepare thin slides of infected tissue: if resting spores are present, the score shall be 4.
5 | S2 | Extremely susceptible | Dense infection fields, numerous ripe non-necrotic sori and sorus fields, fields with dense non-necrotic infection sites, predominant wart formation.