Nevertheless, in order to strengthen mutual trust among Member States, to ensure their better coordination at Union level and to reinforce peer pressure among them, the implementing power to adopt the recommendations for remedial actions in certain cases, as well as to close the action plans in certain cases, should be conferred on the Council given its political role in exerting such peer pressure. Such an implementing power is justified by the fact that specific powers were conferred on the Council, under Article 70 TFEU, in the field of mutual evaluation of the implementation of Union policies within the area of freedom, security and justice. It adequately reflects the purpose of an evaluation mechanism based on this lex specialis, which is, within this particular area, to fulfil a complementary function of monitoring the effectiveness of the practical implementation of Union policies through peer review. Therefore, the Council should adopt recommendations in cases of political importance and general interest for the functioning of the Schengen area. Such cases should be considered to arise where the evaluated Member State substantially contests the content of the draft evaluation report or the nature of a finding, thereby demonstrating that potential problems may have arisen during the evaluation. The same should apply where an evaluation concludes that there exists a serious deficiency, in cases of thematic evaluations, or in cases of first-time evaluations. Equally, as a part of its role in the monitoring phase of the evaluation and monitoring mechanism, the Council should adopt implementing decisions approving the closure of action plans in cases of serious deficiencies and first-time evaluations.
Recital 23, Regulation (EU) 2022/922
In forcesince 9 Jun 2022