For the purpose of adopting the decision on the amounts to be excluded from Union financing pursuant to Article 55(1) of Regulation (EU) 2021/2116, the Commission shall use its own findings and shall take into account the information made available by the Member States during the conformity procedure carried out in accordance with Article 55(3) of that Regulation. The amount to be excluded from Union financing shall as much as possible correspond to the actual financial loss or risk for the Union budget.
Where the Commission finds that the expenditure has not been effected in conformity with Union law, the Commission may determine the amounts to be excluded by applying flat-rate corrections, taking into account the nature and gravity of the infringement and its own estimation of the risk of financial damage caused to the Union.
The level of flat-rate correction shall be established by taking into consideration in particular the type of serious deficiency identified. To this effect, account shall be taken of the elements of the governance systems affected by the serious deficiencies.
If, in the framework of the same conformity procedure, different serious deficiencies which would individually lead to distinct flat-rate corrections are established, then only the highest flat-rate correction shall apply.
When establishing the level of flat-rate corrections, the Commission shall specifically take into account one or more of the following circumstances demonstrating a higher gravity of the deficiencies, revealing a greater risk of loss for the Union budget:
serious deficiencies in one or more elements of the governance systems;
the Member State’s application of an element of the governance system is found to be absent, and there is evidence of wide-spread irregularity and negligence in countering irregular or fraudulent practices;
similar deficiencies in the same sector are detected in a Member State in an enquiry that follows an enquiry in which they have been first detected and communicated to the Member State, account taken however of the corrective or compensating measures already taken by the Member State.
Where a Member State demonstrates that the maximum loss for the EAGF and the EAFRD is lower than or equal to the loss that would derive from the application of a flat rate lower than the one proposed, the Commission may use that lower flat rate or the certification body’s assessment of the governance systems in the context of its audit referred to in Article 12 of Regulation (EU) 2021/2116 to determine the amounts to be excluded from Union financing during the conformity procedure referred to in Article 55 of that Regulation.
Where appropriate, Member States may, within the time-periods set by the Commission during the conformity procedure, submit data concerning the verification of those amounts on the basis of an examination of all individual cases potentially affected by the deficiency. The verification shall cover the entire expenditure incurred in breach of Union law and charged to the Union budget. The data submitted shall include all amounts, which are ineligible due to that non-conformity with Union law. Alternatively, Member States may provide an assessment of the risk, based on a statistically valid and representative sample of the population affected by the deficiency, provided the Member States cannot calculate the amounts unduly spent with proportionate effort. The certification body shall confirm the Member State’s assessment of the deficiency.
In order to take into consideration the results submitted by Member States as referred to in paragraph 5, the Commission shall assess the method, content and results of the verification or extrapolation submitted. Where the Commission is satisfied with the method, content and results of the verification or extrapolation submitted, it shall use the results submitted by Member States pursuant to paragraph 5, in order to determine the amounts to be excluded from Union financing pursuant to Article 55 of Regulation (EU) 2021/2116.
Amounts effectively recovered from the beneficiaries and credited to the EAGF and the EAFRD before a relevant date, to be established by the Commission in the course of the conformity procedure, shall be deducted from the amount that the Commission decides to exclude from Union financing pursuant to Article 55 of Regulation (EU) 2021/2116.