60 3. ASSESSMENT › 3.3. Market analysis › 3.3.2. Conclusion on competitive assessment, Decision_act (EU) 2022/418

In forcesince 10 Mar 2022

The NCA argues on the contrary that the prevalence of certain factors like long contract duration, small volumes tendered, few active tenderers, tends to leave little scope for sustainable competition. It therefore considers, for the purposes of the question referred, that the weight of the argument points to insufficient competition. It is important to note, however, that the NCA’s conclusion considered the competition situation across the whole of Austria and that the NCA recognised very significant differences between the Verkehrsverbünde (regional transport associations). The factors mentioned in the NCA’s position are significantly more relevant for other Austrian regions than those covered by the request. For instance, the rate of competitive tenders stood at only 30 % in Carinthia and 32 % in Tyrol in 2020 (against 92 % and 100 % in the region under the competence of VOR and in the region under the competence of OÖVV). The average number of bidders only reached 2,3 in Vorarlberg, as compared to more than five in the two regions subject to the request. While the market share of the applicant in Salzburg stood at [70 to 80]%, it was below 50 % in both regions subject to the request.