As regards India, a large number of consignments totalling to thousands of tons of allegedly organic sesame seed contaminated with ethylene oxide (‘ETO’) have been imported from that third country, in particular from operators controlled by control bodies supervised by India, and resulting in about 90 notifications in the Organic Farming Information System (OFIS). It appears that the presence of ETO – which is carcinogenic for humans – was detected in organic products before 2020. Various reliable methods for the analysis of ETO have been developed over the last three decades and have therefore been available in order to detect such contaminations. As regards those OFIS notifications, the levels of contamination found in the consignments have usually by far exceeded the maximum residue level established for ETO, with the exact levels of contamination varying depending on the consignment. This has led both to consumers being misled and to a significant health risk. The occurrence of the ETO contamination and the high concentrations found, as well as the lack of response on the root causes of the failure of the control system from the control bodies involved in those contaminations, which are under the supervision of the Indian competent authority, and the inappropriate corrective measures taken by those control bodies and the competent authority, jeopardise the robustness of the controls and the supervision itself. In addition, on the basis of information received by the Commission, it appears that some of the control bodies involved in those OFIS notifications did not respect the scope of recognition of India as regards the products that may be imported into the Union. For all those reasons and in accordance with Article 3, point (a), of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2021/1342, the following control bodies should not appear in the list of control bodies recognised by the Indian competent authority: ‘CU Inspections India Pvt Ltd’, ‘Ecocert India Pvt Ltd’, ‘Indian Organic Certification Agency (Indocert)’, ‘Lacon Quality Certifications Pvt Ltd’ and ‘OneCert International Private Limited’.
Recital 6, Regulation (EU) 2021/2325
In forcesince 16 Dec 2021cited 1×
Judgment of the General Court (Seventh Chamber) of 10 July 2024. Ecocert India Pte Ltd v European Commission.Decision
In that regard, it is important to note that the applicant raised that argument for the first time in its request for a hearing, even though the Commission had pointed out in the defence that the applicant had not disputed several reasons …
10 Jul 2024 · 62022TJ0123