4 APPENDIX 3 Pillar 4 – Financial and technical contribution by the implementing partner, Regulation (EU) 2021/1702

In forcesince 12 Jul 2021

[FVA = financial value added. It represents the difference between the closest market alternative (alternative funding cost) to the final recipient and the price of the loan provided by the implementing partner. The final recipient’s alternative funding cost may be determined by direct reference to a liquid bond or recently signed loan from the same issuer for a duration similar to that of the loan provided by the implementing partner. In co-financings, the most relevant comparison is the parallel commercial facility, provided that the price is known and that the structures are reasonably comparable. Alternatively, if such instrument does not exist, a bond/loan issued by a comparable entity can be employed as a proxy. Market pricing will be derived from the primary and secondary trading levels of the selected bonds or loans including the annualised fees. As a high degree of pricing variability exists for most secondary market bonds, care should be taken that the selected alternative funding cost reflects either longer-term averages or current market conditions if they are expected to prevail.]

Indicators | Fair (= 1) | Good (= 2) | Very good (= 3) | Excellent (= 4)

1.

Financial benefits generated by the intervention of the implementing partner (weight: 12,5 %)

FVA <= 5 bps | 5 bps < FVA<= 30 bps | 30 bps < FVA <= 100 bps | FVA > 100 bps

Any other financing or investment operation not listed in the following sections. | Senior tranches. | Subordinated loans, mezzanine tranches, hybrid bonds, contingent loans and guarantee products. | Equity and quasi-equity operations.

2.

Longer maturity (weight: 25 %)

The final recipient regularly raises funds at similar maturities or the extension of the tenor is less than 30 %. | The final recipient could readily raise funds at similar maturities or extension of the tenor is between 30 % and 49 %. | The final recipient could, with some difficulty, raise funds at similar maturities or extension of the tenor is between 50 % and 99 %. | The final recipient is unable to raise funds at similar maturities or extension of the tenor is 100 % or more.

3.

Other benefit(s) generated for final recipients

(weight: 12,5 %)

Scoring elements applicable:

(a)

flexibility of drawdowns,

(b)

sculpted repayments,

(c)

length of availability period for disbursement,

(d)

length of grace period,

(e)

possibility to convert/revise interest rates,

(f)

length of fixed interest rate period,

(g)

financing in local currency within the EU,

(h)

contribution to diversification and stability of final recipient’s financing,

(i)

subordinated position,

(j)

other, to be specified (such as collateral requirements, as they may arise in the context of the financing or investment operation).

None of the above elements are applicable. | One or two of the above elements are applicable. | Three to four of the above elements are applicable. | At least five of the above elements are applicable.

4.

Crowding-in and signalling effect

(weight: 25 %)

The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is not expected to have: (i) catalytic effect on attracting other co-financiers/guarantors/investors. (e.g. IP co-finances with borrower’s own funds only);

and/or (ii) any signalling effect in the respective market.

The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to have some impact on mobilising other co-financiers/guarantors/investors and signalling that the operation/investments are expected to be sound and worth supporting, thereby facilitating the full financing and implementation. | The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to have a significant impact on other financiers’/guarantors’/investors’ decision to commit to or to co-invest alongside the operation, thus having a strong catalytic effect. This includes situations whereby the implementing partner has been instrumental in combining its funding with third party grants or other forms of external support for specific projects/programmes. | The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to be key for the materialisation of the operation and/or achieving targeted financing level (without the IP, the project is not likely to go ahead or not with the same speed or size). This includes e.g. i) implementing partner taking the role of corner stone investor, ii) the combination of the loans by the implementing partner with third party public and/or private resources.

5.

Financial advice and/or structuring expertise

(weight: 12,5 %)

The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is not required, and the involvement of the implementing partner is expected to be marginal. Origination of the investment does not benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is expected to have a positive impact on the financing structure of the investment and is expected to be of value to the counterparty, and/or origination of the investment is expected to benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is expected to have a significant impact on the financing structure of the investment and is expected to be of significant value to the counterparty (e.g. through accelerating financial close or applying standardised structures, etc.) and/or origination of the investment is expected to benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The contribution of the implementing partner with its financial structuring expertise is expected to be innovative and to have a high value to the counterparty (e.g. through accelerating financial close significantly or applying standardised structures to complex cases, technical assistance or advisory support for the financial structuring of the operation, financial sector experts, etc.).

6.

Technical advice and contribution

(weight: 12,5 %)

The technical expertise and/or advisory services of the implementing partner were not needed by the final recipient. |

The technical advice of the implementing partner ensures the quality of the investment through project-specific disbursement conditions, ad-hoc interventions (e.g. monitoring missions to ensure compliance with disbursement conditions).

OR

Annual project progress reports.

The implementing partner supports the technical preparation or structuring of the financing or investment operation to align it better with the policy objectives.

OR

Targeted inputs (technical, economic, procurement, climate, environment, social), and valuable guidance on project features or design options, regular interventions (e.g. monitoring missions to ensure compliance with standards).

OR

Targeted monitoring (procurement, climate, environment, social).

The implementing partner supports the technical preparation or structuring of the financing or investment operation to align it fully with the policy objectives.

OR

The implementing partner’s technical support has a major impact on the technical or economic quality of the investment, notably through specific technical assistance or advisory support provided.

OR

Significant physical monitoring, such as for complex projects or high-risk projects.

Indicators | Fair (= 1) | Good (= 2) | Very good (= 3) | Excellent (= 4)

1.

Financial benefits generated by the intervention of the implementing partner

(weight: 35 %)

Any other financing or investment operation not listed in the following sections. | Senior tranches. | Subordinated loans, mezzanine tranches, hybrid bonds, contingent loans and guarantee products. | Equity and quasi-equity operations.

2.

Crowding-in and signalling effect

(weight: 40 %)

The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is not expected to have: (i) catalytic effect on attracting other co-financiers/guarantors/investors. (e.g. IP co-finances with borrower’s own funds only);

and/or (ii) any signalling effect in the respective market.

The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to have some impact on mobilising other co-financiers/guarantors/investors and signalling that the investments are expected to be sound and worth supporting, thereby facilitating the full financing and implementation. | The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to have a significant impact on other financiers’/guarantors’/investors’ decision to commit to or to co-invest alongside the operation, thus having a strong catalytic effect. This includes situations whereby the implementing partner has been instrumental in combining its funding with third party grants or other forms of external support for specific projects/programmes. | The involvement of the implementing partner in the financing or investment operation is expected to be key for the materialisation of the operation and/or achieving targeted financing level. This includes e.g. (i) implementing partner taking the role of corner stone investor; (ii) the combination of the loans by the implementing partner with third party public and/or private resources.

3.

Financial advice and structuring expertise

(weight: 12,5 %)

The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is not required, and the involvement of the implementing partner is expected to be marginal. Origination of the investment does not benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is expected to have a positive impact on the financing structure of the investment and is expected to be of value to the counterparty, and/or origination of the investment is expected to benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The financial structuring expertise of the implementing partner is expected to have a significant impact on the financing structure of the investment and is expected to be of significant value to the counterparty (e.g. through accelerating financial close or applying standardised structures, etc.) and/or origination of the investment is expected to benefit from the expertise of the implementing partner. | The contribution of the implementing partner with its financial structuring expertise is expected to be innovative and to have a high value to the counterparty (e.g. through accelerating financial close significantly or applying standardised structures to complex cases, technical assistance or advisory support for the financial structuring of the operation, financial sector experts, etc.).

4.

Technical advice and contribution

(weight: 12,5 %)

The implementing partner is not expected to provide any technical advice or capacity building to the intermediary. | The implementing partner is expected to set particular conditions related to the implementation of the underlying transactions and provides advice to the intermediary to select them or expects that advice in the implementation of the criteria related to the financing or investment operation will be needed by the intermediary. | The implementing partner expects to participate in the technical assistance or training provided to the intermediary in order to improve its performance or capacity to meet requirements (e.g. on reporting, eligibility, sustainability aspects and procurement standards). The assistance is expected to go beyond the standard due diligence of the IP at appraisal stage. | Extensive technical assistance or advice is expected to be provided to support the intermediary to develop business segments of particular impact as reflected in InvestEU policy areas. The assistance is expected to go beyond the standard due diligence of the IP at appraisal stage.