In addition, concerning the existence of a single economic entity, the Commission recalled that under Union case law the existence of a written commission agreement only on the export sales is an important element tending to show that the trader is not an internal sales department of the exporting producers as far as export sales are concerned [Judgment of the General Court of 25 June 2015 in case T-26/12, PT Musim Mas, para 50, confirmed by the Court of Justice when deciding about the appeal in case C-468/15 P of 26 October 2016, paragraphs 43-44.]. The contract also contains numerous clauses, such as an arbitration clause, showing a lack of solidarity between the companies. These clauses were difficult to reconcile with the claim that the exporting producers and the related trader should be treated as a single economic entity despite being legally distinct companies. It also appeared that some sales functions were retained by the exporting producers in view of their SG&A expenses to that effect. Finally, the Commission noted that the related trader issued the invoices in the name of the exporting produces to the first independent customers in the Union. In view of the above considerations, the Commission provisionally rejected the claim that the trader and the exporting producers constitute a single economic entity as far as export sales are concerned..
68 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Normal value › 3.2.2. Comparison, Regulation (EU) 2021/940
Judgment of the General Court (Sixth Chamber) of 11 September 2024. Sveza Verkhnyaya Sinyachikha NAO and Others v European Commission.Decision
In the present case, it is apparent from recitals 67, 68 and 71 of the provisional regulation and recitals 95, 97 to 106, 108 and 113 of the contested regulation that the Commission relied, in essence, on four factors in order to reject …
11 Sep 2024 · 62022TJ0002
Judgment of the Court (Ninth Chamber) of 26 October 2016. PT Perindustrian dan Perdagangan Musim Semi Mas (PT Musim Mas) v Council of the EuDecision
26 Oct 2016 · 62015CJ0468
Arrêt du Tribunal (septième chambre) du 25 juin 2015. PT Perindustrian dan Perdagangan Musim Semi Mas (PT Musim Mas) contre Conseil de l'UniDecision
25 Jun 2015 · 62012TJ0026
- celex=31926D0012