In return proceedings under the 1980 Hague Convention, the courts at every instance should give their decision within six weeks, except where exceptional circumstances make this impossible. The fact that means of alternative dispute resolution are used should not as such be considered an exceptional circumstance allowing the timeframe to be exceeded. However, exceptional circumstances might arise while using such means or as a result of them. For a court of first instance, the timeframe should start at the moment that the court is seised. For a court of higher instance, it should start at the moment that all required procedural steps have been taken. Such steps could include, depending on the legal system concerned, service of the appeal upon the respondent, either within the Member State where the court is located or within another Member State, transmission of the file and the appeal to the appellate court in Member States where the appeal has to be lodged with the court whose decision is appealed, or an application by a party to convene a hearing where such an application is required under national law. Member States should also consider limiting the number of appeals possible against a decision granting or refusing the return of a child under the 1980 Hague Convention to one.
Recital 42, Regulation (EU) 2019/1111
In forcesince 25 Jun 2019cited 1×
Opinion of Advocate General Emiliou delivered on 12 January 2023. T.C. and Others.Decision
One final point must be dealt with as a postscript. As I stated above, the Brussels IIb Regulation has been applicable to return applications since 1 August 2022. That new regulation confirmed the solutions laid down in the Brussels IIa …
12 Jan 2023 · 62022CC0638