In its previous decisions relating to pet food, the Commission found that: (i)
industrial dog and cat food is a distinct market, separate from home prepared pet food;
17 (ii) dog food and cat food are not part of the same relevant product market;
18 (iii) dry dog food, wet dog food, dry cat food, and wet cat food products each constitute a separate product market;
19 and (iv) it cannot be excluded that
13 Form CO, paragraphs 103, 113, 116-117, 119-124, 127; Parties' supplemental submission on market definition and substitution, 22 October 2018.
14 Form CO, paragraph 124(a)-(e).
15 Form CO, paragraphs 145-146, 150-151.
16 Form CO, paragraphs 107, 118; Parties' response to RFI 1, question 2, paragraph 2.18.
17 Case IV/M.554 - Dalgety/The Quaker Oats Company, paragraph 12; confirmed in Case IV/M.1127 - Nestlé/Dalgety, paragraph 8 (this question was left open in that case, as the assessment of the competitive impact of the case did not change whether grocery and non-grocery stores were considered together or separately).
18 Case IV/M.1127 - Nestlé/Dalgety, paragraph 13; Case M.2337 – Nestlé/Ralston Purina, paragraph 10.
19 Case M.2337 – Nestlé/Ralston Purina, paragraph 12; Case M.2544 – Masterfoods/Royal Canin, paragraphs 9-11. specialist (non-grocery) stores are a separate relevant product market from grocery stores.20