Taking into account the criteria set out in Article 14(3)(e) of Delegated Decision 2012/678/EU, the Commission in its report concluded that STAT and all entities concerned have shown a high degree of cooperation in the course of the investigation. This element would normally justify a reduction of the amount of the fine. Nevertheless, it has been ascertained that, under the principle of due diligence, STAT could and should have had a more prompt and pro-active role in informing the Commission (Eurostat) that misreporting had occurred in the accounts of Land Salzburg. This element would normally justify an increase in the amount of the fine. However, this conclusion should be qualified by the high complexity of the factual situation which led to the misreporting, involving losses from financial derivatives and the associated technical difficulties associated to their understanding and elaboration and which should be taken into account when assessing the degree of diligence shown by the authorities of the Member State concerned. Considering the combined effect of the elements justifying a reduction – the high degree of cooperation shown in the course of the investigation as well as the difficulties ensuing from the high complexity of the facts – against the elements justifying an increase, a reduction should still be applied to the amount of the fine.
Recital 13, Decision_act (EU) 2018/818
In forcesince 28 May 2018