69 G. INVALIDATION OF UNDERTAKING INVOICES, Regulation (EU) 2017/1408

In forcesince 1 Aug 2017

The Commission first recalls that the ‘product covered’ by the undertaking are only those solar panels that are explicitly referred to in recital (6). The MIP is not applicable for products not covered by the undertaking, in particular for solar panels falling outside the scope defined in recital (6). It is meaningless to compare the sales price of the product not covered by the undertaking to the alleged MIP. These products were not subject to the investigation; hence their price cannot be verified and compared to the alleged MIP. Topray Solar should not have issued undertaking invoices at all for products not covered by the undertaking. By issuing these undertaking invoices in breach of the undertaking, Topray Solar was in position to conceal the excess of the parallel sales limit. The sales of controllers referred to by the fifth importer constitute yet an additional layer to the already existing breach of the parallel sales limit as referred in recital (44). As regards the reasonable time limit to provide comments, the Commission recalls that despite the extension granted to the fourth importer, it failed to submit further comments on the substance of the disclosure. The Commission therefore rejects these arguments.