ECAIs have been classifying unsolicited credit ratings according to different definitions. This is reflected in the submission of information by ECAIs both to the EBA and to ESMA's CEREP database. In response to these divergences in practices across ECAIs, ESMA issued a ‘Q&A’ [https://www.esma.europa.eu/file/13634/download?token=05de9eN_] on the definition of unsolicited rating, setting out its views on it, which, for consistency, should also be employed for the purposes of the assessment exercise under Article 138 CRR. Nevertheless, as the assessment exercise started earlier in time than, and was one of the triggers for the Q&A, it is appropriate for the purposes of this Decision, to assess the ratings considering their classification as assigned by each ECAI before the publication of the Q&A (i.e. 16 December 2015), as this would allow to consider the historical information on unsolicited ratings, and to use the only available quantitative data for such ratings, as provided in the CEREP database. In addition this would help avoid an overly delay of the entry into force of this Decision, especially in view of the impact the Q&A has on how ECAIs classify their unsolicited ratings, their policies, and how those ratings are used by institutions for regulatory purposes. Nevertheless, based on updates by ESMA regarding progress with adoption by ECAIs of the definition of unsolicited rating as further specified in the Q&A, the EBA will assess whether further action should be taken in the context of this Decision.
Recital 5, Decision of the European Banking Authority confirming that the unsolicited credit assess…
In forcesince 17 May 2016