70 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. PRESENCE OF AID › 5.1.2. EXISTENCE OF A SELECTIVE ADVANTAGE › 5.1.2.2. Selectivity › Justification by the nature and logic of the tax system, Decision_act (EU) 2016/2391

In forcesince 4 Jul 2016cited 2×

The effective taxation from which the four sport clubs benefited therefore tends to be lower in comparison to the normal taxation for limited companies active in professional sport, as illustrated by the figures provided by Spain and reproduced in recital 35, even if one considers, as referred to by Real Madrid, the different possibilities for limited companies and non-profit entities to deduct the reinvestment of extraordinary profit or capital gains received from equity transfers in a given year in which those reinvestments or transfers took place. Therefore, reserving to the four clubs the non-profit tax treatment, including a lower taxation rate than to other professional sport clubs is not in the logic of any tax system and has the effect of a tax advantage for certain clubs [This reasoning is similar to the one in Case T-211/05 Italian Republic v Commission ECLI:EU:T:2009:304, paragraphs 120 and 121 (confirmed by the Court of Justice in Case C-458/09 P — Italy v Commission ECLI:EU:C:2011:769, paragraph 60), which considered selective a tax advantage available only to undertakings admitted to listing on a regulated market during a brief period, whereas all other undertakings were excluded from the advantages conferred by that scheme because they could not satisfy the conditions required for listing during the period covered by the aid scheme.]. The comments of Spain and interested parties did not provide elements of law or fact which would affect the preliminary conclusions of the Commission in the opening decision regarding the presence of an advantage.

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (quatrième chambre) du 26 février 2019. Athletic Club contre Commission européenne.Decision

    Dans la décision attaquée, la Commission, après avoir rappelé les arguments avancés par les parties intéressées et le Royaume d’Espagne relatifs aux impositions effectives qui résultent, respectivement, du régime de droit commun …

    26 Feb 2019 · 62016TJ0679

  • Judgment of the General Court (Fourth Chamber) of 26 February 2019. Fútbol Club Barcelona v European Commission.Decision

    The contested decision also relies on a study submitted by the Kingdom of Spain during the administrative procedure, data from which are set out in recital 35, and from which it is apparent that, between 2008 and 2011, with the exception …

    26 Feb 2019 · 62016TJ0865