36 3. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › 3.1. On a possible violation of Article 110 of the Treaty, Decision_act (EU) 2016/2042

In force

ANGA, which also represents VoD providers in Germany, on the other hand, finds a discrimination of domestic providers because they are subject to taxation of their domestic offer, while the non-domestic competitors competing with them with offers tailored for the same market are not subject to taxation of the relevant turnover just because they chose to elect domicile abroad. SPIO, VPRT, Produzentenallianz and MDM also suggest that the tax would end a discrimination of domestic providers. According to SPIO, the main part of the turnover with VoD in Germany is made by 13 undertakings, of which 6 are established abroad. These figures do not yet include the recent entry into the market of a leading VoD provider from the United States which is established in the Netherlands. For SPIO the decisive element for taxation should not be the more or less fortuitous location of the provider. In the digital era a provider does not need more than one place of establishment in the internal market. The more relevant question for taxation should be whether the provider acquires film licences for the German market to do business there with final consumers. SPIO also points to data collected by it which shows that the foreign VoD providers have in their offer a similar focus on German productions as the domestic providers.