82 4. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › Comments submitted by Confindustria, Decision_act (EU) 2016/195

In forcesince 14 Aug 2015

As for the conditions relied upon by the Commission, Confindustria acknowledges that for some of the measures at issue a formal definition of damage would seem to be missing; the same applies to the determination of the correlation and proportion between the amount of damage suffered and the amount of the aid. However, Confindustria suggests that such a correlation does exist de facto — that in the event of a natural disaster all undertakings suffer damage (at least economic loss), and that a simplified method for estimating the damage and the corresponding aid could be devised. Such a method should take into account, for example, the capacity to create revenue and the number of people employed by each undertaking. The problem is therefore related to cases of overcompensation rather than to the compatibility of the measures with the State aid rules. It is important to avoid a situation in which action against a few cases of overcompensation might lead to the penalisation of a large majority of undertakings which have received benefits in good faith and in compliance with the law. Confindustria therefore suggests that undertakings should be allowed to keep the aid despite the fact that at the time of its approval, if the Italian authorities had complied with the Treaty and the notification obligation, the aid ought to have been notified to the Commission.