132 6. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURES › Appraisal of the compatibility of the aid with the internal market in the light of the comments by interested parties › Comments by interested parties, Decision_act (EU) 2016/195

In forcesince 14 Aug 2015

Chiti and Confindustria also say that the aid provided for by some of the measures was granted only after the actual damage suffered by each undertaking had been verified. The possibility cannot be ruled out that in specific cases the aid granted under the measures did not exceed the amount needed to make good the actual damage suffered by the beneficiary as a direct result of the disaster, so that the aid granted to the particular undertaking should be regarded as compatible with the internal market under Article 107(2)(b). However, the measures in question are not, by their nature and operational arrangements, designed to rule out any form of overcompensation of damage, and only to make good the damage caused by the natural disaster. As explained in the preceding section (‘Aid to make good the damage caused by natural disasters’), their scope is far wider, because they do not require that the aid be linked directly to the damage suffered as a result of the natural disaster. By failing to make such a link, they fail to confine the compensation to the amount needed to make good the damage actually suffered by the undertakings. Even where beneficiaries are required to prove that they have suffered heavy damage, as in the case of Piedmont, the legislation does not limit the amount of aid to the ascertained loss caused by the floods. As for the Italian authorities' comments regarding the impact of the 2009 earthquake on the social and economic fabric of Abruzzo, and more specifically on the area affected by this exceptionally violent and destructive earthquake, the Commission points out once again that, according to the Treaty and in line with the Commission's settled practice [See, for example, Commission Decision 2005/315/EC of 20 October 2004 on the aid scheme implemented by Italy for firms investing in municipalities seriously affected by natural disasters in 2002 (OJ L 100, 20.4.2005, p. 46).], there must be a clear and direct link between the event that caused the damage and the State aid intended to remedy it. Such a link must be established at the level of the individual undertaking, and not at the macroeconomic level, as in the case of the measure under investigation (for the Abruzzo earthquake of 2009, the notified measure that is the subject of case SA.35083 (12/C)).