G. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS › (i) Chint Solar › Sales by the related producer in the Union, Regulation (EU) 2015/2018

In forcesince 11 Nov 2015
(42)

Chint Solar also contested that it had breached the obligation under the undertaking not to enter into a compensatory arrangement for the following reasons:

(a)

Chint Solar notified the Commission on the acquisition of the module producer in the Union referred to in recital 19 above and the Commission has not reacted,

(b)

the complexity of the undertaking in general led the Commission to issue different replies for the same scenario over the time. Therefore, it is reasonable that Chint Solar did not consider the risk of compensatory arrangements until the disclosure on the intention to withdraw the undertaking by the Commission,

(c)

the sales of the related producer in the Union should not be subject to the terms of the undertaking which only covers modules and cells originating in or consigned from the PRC,

(d)

Chint Solar had no intention for any cross-compensation by selling to the same Chint Solar customer from PRC and the related producer in the Union. The difference in the product specifications and the trading habit of the particular Chint Solar customer justifies these parallel sales. Chint Solar also claimed that the sales price of the related producer in the Union was in line with the market price. In addition, Chint Solar committed to stop selling the product concerned to that Chint Solar customer from the PRC, to provide quarterly reports on the sales of its related producer in the Union and to allow for verifying the accuracy of these reports.