Medium power transformers shall comply with the maximum allowed load and no-load losses or the Peak Efficiency Index (PEI) values set out in Tables I.1 to I.5, excluding medium power pole-mounted transformers, which shall comply with the maximum allowed load and no load losses values set out in Table I.6.
As of the date of application of Tier 2 requirements (1 July 2021), when the one-to-one replacement of an existing medium power transformer entails disproportionate costs associated with their installation, the replacement transformer is, exceptionally, only required to meet Tier 1 requirements for the given rated power.
In this respect, installation costs are disproportionate if the costs of the replacement of the complete substation housing the transformer and/or the acquisition or rental of additional floor space are higher than the net present value of the additional avoided electricity losses (tariffs, taxes and levies excluded) of a Tier 2 compliant replacement transformer over its normally expected service life. The net present value shall be calculated based on capitalised loss values using widely accepted social discount rates [The European Commission Better Regulation Toolbox suggest using a value of 4 % for the social discount rate https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/file_import/better-regulation-toolbox-61_en_0.pdf].
In this case, the manufacturer, importer, or authorised representative shall include in the technical documentation of the replacement transformer the following information:
Address and contact details of the commissioner of the replacement transformer
The station where the replacement transformer is to be installed. This shall be unequivocally identified by either a specific location or a specific installation type (e.g., station or cabin model)
The technical and/or economic justification of the disproportionate cost to install a transformer that is only Tier 1 compliant instead of a Tier 2 compliant one. If the transformers(s) were commissioned by a tendering process, all the necessary information regarding the analysis of bids and the award decision shall be provided.
In the above cases, the manufacturer, importer or authorised representative shall notify the competent national market surveillance authorities.
[Maximum losses for kVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.1 shall be obtained by linear interpolation.]
Tier 1 (from 1 July 2015) | Tier 2 (from 1 July 2021)
Rated Power (kVA) | Maximum load losses Pk (W) | Maximum no-load losses Po (W) | Maximum load losses Pk (W) | Maximum no-load losses Po (W)
≤ 25 | Ck (900) | Ao (70) | Ak (600) | Ao – 10 % (63)
50 | Ck (1100) | Ao (90) | Ak (750) | Ao – 10 % (81)
100 | Ck (1750) | Ao (145) | Ak (1250) | Ao – 10 % (130)
160 | Ck (2350) | Ao (210) | Ak (1750) | Ao – 10 % (189)
250 | Ck (3250) | Ao (300) | Ak (2350) | Ao – 10 % (270)
315 | Ck (3900) | Ao (360) | Ak (2800) | Ao – 10 % (324)
400 | Ck (4600) | Ao (430) | Ak (3250) | Ao – 10 % (387)
500 | Ck (5500) | Ao (510) | Ak (3900) | Ao – 10 % (459)
630 | Ck (6500) | Ao (600) | Ak (4600) | Ao – 10 % (540)
800 | Ck (8400) | Ao (650) | Ak (6000) | Ao – 10 % (585)
1000 | Ck (10500) | Ao (770) | Ak (7600) | Ao – 10 % (693)
1250 | Bk (11000) | Ao (950) | Ak (9500) | Ao – 10 % (855)
1600 | Bk (14000) | Ao (1200) | Ak (12000) | Ao – 10 % (1080)
2000 | Bk (18000) | Ao (1450) | Ak (15000) | Ao – 10 % (1305)
2500 | Bk (22000) | Ao (1750) | Ak (18500) | Ao – 10 % (1575)
3150 | Bk (27500) | Ao (2200) | Ak (23000) | Ao – 10 % (1980)
[Maximum losses for kVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.2 shall be obtained by linear interpolation.]
Tier 1 (1 July 2015) | Tier 2 (1 July 2021)
Rated Power (kVA) | Maximum load losses Pk (W) | Maximum no-load losses Po (W) | Maximum load losses Pk (W) | Maximum no-load losses Po (W)
≤ 50 | Bk (1700) | Ao (200) | Ak (1500) | Ao – 10 % (180)
100 | Bk (2050) | Ao (280) | Ak (1800) | Ao – 10 % (252)
160 | Bk (2900) | Ao (400) | Ak (2600) | Ao – 10 % (360)
250 | Bk (3800) | Ao (520) | Ak (3400) | Ao – 10 % (468)
400 | Bk (5500) | Ao (750) | Ak (4500) | Ao – 10 % (675)
630 | Bk (7600) | Ao (1100) | Ak (7100) | Ao – 10 % (990)
800 | Ak (8000) | Ao (1300) | Ak (8000) | Ao – 10 % (1170)
1000 | Ak (9000) | Ao (1550) | Ak (9000) | Ao – 10 % (1395)
1250 | Ak (11000) | Ao (1800) | Ak (11000) | Ao – 10 % (1620)
1600 | Ak (13000) | Ao (2200) | Ak (13000) | Ao – 10 % (1980)
2000 | Ak (16000) | Ao (2600) | Ak (16000) | Ao – 10 % (2340)
2500 | Ak (19000) | Ao (3100) | Ak (19000) | Ao – 10 % (2790)
3150 | Ak (22000) | Ao (3800) | Ak (22000) | Ao – 10 % (3420)
Special combination of voltages in one winding | Load losses (Pk) | No load losses (Po)
For both liquid immersed (Table I.1) and dry type (Table I.2) | No correction | No correction
Primary highest voltage for equipment Um ≤ 24kV | Secondary highest voltage for equipment Um > 3,6 kV
For liquid immersed (Table I.1) | 10 % | 15 %
Primary highest voltage for equipment Um = 36kV | Secondary highest voltage for equipment Um ≤ 3,6 kV
Primary highest voltage for equipment Um = 36kV | Secondary highest voltage for equipment Um > 3,6 kV | 10 % | 15 %
For dry type (Table I.2) | 10 % | 15 %
Primary highest voltage for equipment Um = 36kV | Secondary highest voltage for equipment Um ≤ 3,6 kV
Primary highest voltage for equipment Um = 36kV | Secondary highest voltage for equipment Um > 3,6 kV | 15 % | 20 %
[The losses shall be calculated on the base of the voltage of the winding specified in the second column and can be increased with the correction factors given in the last 2 columns. In any case, whatever the combinations of winding voltages, the losses cannot exceed the values given in Tables I.1, I.2 and I.6 corrected by the factors in this table.]
Type of dual voltage | Reference voltage for the application of correction factors | Load losses (Pk) | No load losses (Po)
Dual voltage on one winding with reduced power output on the lower low-voltage winding
AND
maximum available power on the lower voltage of the low-voltage winding limited to 0,85 of the rated power assigned to the low-voltage winding at its higher voltage.
losses shall be calculated based on the higher voltage of the low-voltage winding | No correction | No correction
Dual voltage on one winding with reduced power output on the lower high-voltage winding
AND
maximum available power on the lower voltage of the high-voltage winding limited to 0,85 of the rated power assigned to the high-voltage winding at its higher voltage.
losses shall be calculated based on the higher voltage of the high-voltage winding | No correction | No correction
Dual voltage on one winding
AND
full rated power available on both windings, i.e., the full nominal power is available regardless of the combination of voltages.
The losses shall be calculated based on the higher voltage of the dual voltage winding | 10 % | 15 %
Dual voltage on both windings
AND
rated power available on all combinations of windings, i.e., both voltages on one winding are fully rated in combination with one of the voltages on the other winding
the losses shall be calculated based on the higher voltages of both dual voltage windings | 20 % | 20 %
Rated Power (kVA) | Tier 1 (1 July 2015) | Tier 2 (1 July 2021)
Minimum Peak Efficiency Index (%)
3150 < Sr ≤ 4000 | 99,465 | 99,532
5000 | 99,483 | 99,548
6300 | 99,510 | 99,571
8000 | 99,535 | 99,593
10000 | 99,560 | 99,615
12500 | 99,588 | 99,640
16000 | 99,615 | 99,663
20000 | 99,639 | 99,684
25000 | 99,657 | 99,700
31500 | 99,671 | 99,712
40000 | 99,684 | 99,724
Minimum PEI values for kVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.4 shall be calculated by linear interpolation.
Rated Power (kVA) | Tier 1 (1 July 2015) | Tier 2 (1 July 2021)
Minimum Peak Efficiency Index (%)
3150 < Sr ≤ 4000 | 99,348 | 99,382
5000 | 99,354 | 99,387
6300 | 99,356 | 99,389
8000 | 99,357 | 99,390
≥ 10000 | 99,357 | 99,390
Minimum PEI values for kVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.5 shall be calculated by linear interpolation.
The maximum allowable levels of losses set out in Tables I.1 and I.2 shall be increased by 20 % for no load losses and 5 % for load losses in Tier 1 and by 10 % for no load losses in Tier 2.
For the one-to-one replacement of existing medium power pole-mounted transformers, the manufacturer, importer or authorised representative shall include in the technical documentation of the transformer the following information:
the address and contact details of the commissioner of the replacement transformer;
the station where the replacement transformer is to be installed. This shall be unequivocally identified either by a specific location or an specific installation type (e.g. technical description of the pole).
In the above cases, the manufacturer, importer or authorised representative shall notify the competent national market surveillance authorities.
With regard to the installation of new pole-mounted transformers, it is the requirements in Tables I.1 and I.2, in conjunction with Tables I.3a and I.3b where justified, which are applicable.
[Maximum allowable losses for kVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.6 shall be obtained by linear interpolation.]
Tier 1 (1 July 2015) | Tier 2 (1 July 2021)
Rated Power (kVA) | Maximum load losses (in W) | Maximum no-load losses (in W) | Maximum load losses (in W) | Maximum no-load losses (in W)
25 | Ck (900) | Ao (70) | Bk (725) | Ao (70)
50 | Ck (1100) | Ao (90) | Bk (875) | Ao (90)
100 | Ck (1750) | Ao (145) | Bk (1475) | Ao (145)
160 | Ck + 32 % (3102) | Co (300) | Ck + 32 % (3102) | Co – 10 % (270)
200 | Ck (2750) | Co (356) | Bk (2333) | Bo (310)
250 | Ck (3250) | Co (425) | Bk (2750) | Bo (360)
315 | Ck (3900) | Co (520) | Bk (3250) | Bo (440)
Minimum efficiency requirements for large power transformers are set out in Tables I.7, I.8 and I.9.
There may be specific instances where the replacement of an existing transformer, or the installation of a new one, meeting the applicable minimum requirements set out in Tables I.7, I.8 and I.9 would result in disproportionate costs. As general rule, costs can be considered to be disproportionate when the extra transportation and/or installation costs of a Tier 2 or Tier 1, as applicable, compliant transformer would be higher than the net present value of the additional avoided electricity losses (tariffs, taxes and levies excluded) over its normally expected service life. This net present value shall be calculated based on capitalised loss values using widely accepted social discount rates [The European Commission Better Regulation Toolbox suggest using a value of 4 % for the social discount rate https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/file_import/better-regulation-toolbox-61_en_0.pdf].
In those cases, the following fall-back provisions apply:
As of the date of application of Tier 2 requirements (1 July 2021), when the one-to-one replacement of a large power transformers in an existing site entails disproportionate costs associated to its transportation and/or installation, or is technically infeasible, the replacement transformer is, exceptionally, only required to comply with Tier 1 requirements for the given rated power.
Furthermore, if the cost of installing a replacement transformer complying with Tier 1 requirements are also disproportionate, or where no technically feasible solutions exist, no minimum requirements shall apply to the replacement transformer.
As of the date of application of Tier 2 requirements (1 July 2021), when the installation of a new large power transformer in a new site entails disproportionate costs associated to their transportation and/or installation, or is technically infeasible, the new transformer is, exceptionally, only required to meet Tier 1 requirements for the given rated power.
In these cases, the manufacturer, importer or authorised representative responsible for placing on the market or putting into service the transformer shall:
include in the technical documentation of the new or replacement transformer the following information:
address and contact details of the commissioner of the transformer,
the specific location where the transformer is to be installed,
the technical and/or economic justification to install a new or replacement transformer that does not comply with Tier 2 or Tier 1 requirements. If the transformer(s) were commissioned by a tendering process, all the necessary information regarding the analysis of bids and the award decision, shall also be provided,
notify the competent national market surveillance authorities.
Rated Power (MVA) | Tier 1 (1.7.2015) | Tier 2 (1.7.2021)
Minimum Peak Efficiency Index (%)
≤ 0,025 | 97,742 | 98,251
0,05 | 98,584 | 98,891
0,1 | 98,867 | 99,093
0,16 | 99,012 | 99,191
0,25 | 99,112 | 99,283
0,315 | 99,154 | 99,320
0,4 | 99,209 | 99,369
0,5 | 99,247 | 99,398
0,63 | 99,295 | 99,437
0,8 | 99,343 | 99,473
1 | 99,360 | 99,484
1,25 | 99,418 | 99,487
1,6 | 99,424 | 99,494
2 | 99,426 | 99,502
2,5 | 99,441 | 99,514
3,15 | 99,444 | 99,518
4 | 99,465 | 99,532
5 | 99,483 | 99,548
6,3 | 99,510 | 99,571
8 | 99,535 | 99,593
10 | 99,560 | 99,615
12,5 | 99,588 | 99,640
16 | 99,615 | 99,663
20 | 99,639 | 99,684
25 | 99,657 | 99,700
31,5 | 99,671 | 99,712
40 | 99,684 | 99,724
50 | 99,696 | 99,734
63 | 99,709 | 99,745
80 | 99,723 | 99,758
100 | 99,737 | 99,770
125 | 99,737 | 99,780
160 | 99,737 | 99,790
≥ 200 | 99,737 | 99,797
Minimum PEI values for MVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.7 shall be calculated by linear interpolation
Rated Power (MVA) | Tier 1 (1.7.2015) | Tier 2 (1.7.2021)
Minimum Peak Efficiency Index (%)
3,15 < Sr ≤ 4 | 99,348 | 99,382
5 | 99,354 | 99,387
6,3 | 99,356 | 99,389
8 | 99,357 | 99,390
≥ 10 | 99,357 | 99,390
Minimum PEI values for MVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.8 shall be calculated by linear interpolation
Rated Power (MVA) | Tier 1 (1.7.2015) | Tier 2 (1.7.2021)
Minimum Peak Efficiency Index (%)
≤ 0,05 | 96,174 | 96,590
0,1 | 97,514 | 97,790
0,16 | 97,792 | 98,016
0,25 | 98,155 | 98,345
0,4 | 98,334 | 98,570
0,63 | 98,494 | 98,619
0,8 | 98,677 | 98,745
1 | 98,775 | 98,837
1,25 | 98,832 | 98,892
1,6 | 98,903 | 98,960
2 | 98,942 | 98,996
2,5 | 98,933 | 99,045
3,15 | 99,048 | 99,097
4 | 99,158 | 99,225
5 | 99,200 | 99,265
6,3 | 99,242 | 99,303
8 | 99,298 | 99,356
10 | 99,330 | 99,385
12,5 | 99,370 | 99,422
16 | 99,416 | 99,464
20 | 99,468 | 99,513
25 | 99,521 | 99,564
31,5 | 99,551 | 99,592
40 | 99,567 | 99,607
50 | 99,585 | 99,623
≥ 63 | 99,590 | 99,626
Minimum PEI values for MVA ratings that fall in between the ratings given in Table I.9 shall be calculated by linear interpolation.
From 1 July 2015, the following product information requirements for transformers included in the scope of this Regulation (Article 1) shall be included in any related product documentation, including free access websites of manufacturers:
information on rated power, load loss and no-load loss and the electrical power of any cooling system required at no load;
for medium power (where applicable) and large power transformers, the value of the Peak Efficiency Index and the power at which it occurs;
for dual voltage transformers, the maximum rated power at the lower voltage, according to Table I.3;
information on the weight of all the main components of a power transformer (including at least the conductor, the nature of the conductor and the core material);
For medium power pole mounted transformers, a visible display ‘For pole-mounted operation only’.
For medium and large power transformers only, the information under (a); (c) and (d) shall also be included on the rating plate of the transformer.
The following information shall be included in the technical documentation of power transformers:
manufacturer's name and address;
model identifier, the alphanumeric code to distinguish one model from other models of the same manufacturer;
the information required under point 3;
the specific reason(s) why transformers are considered to be exempted from the Regulation in accordance with Article 1.2.
If (parts of) the technical documentation is based upon (parts of) the technical documentation of another model, the model identifier of that model shall be provided and the technical documentation shall provide the details of how the information is derived from the technical documentation of the other model, e.g. on calculations or extrapolations, including the tests undertaken by the manufacturer to verify the calculations or extrapolations undertaken.