In the absence of Union rules on the quantification of harm caused by a competition law infringement, it is for the domestic legal system of each Member State to determine its own rules on quantifying harm, and for the Member States and for the national courts to determine what requirements the claimant has to meet when proving the amount of the harm suffered, the methods that can be used in quantifying the amount, and the consequences of not being able to fully meet those requirements. However, the requirements of national law regarding the quantification of harm in competition law cases should not be less favourable than those governing similar domestic actions (principle of equivalence), nor should they render the exercise of the Union right to damages practically impossible or excessively difficult (principle of effectiveness). Regard should be had to any information asymmetries between the parties and to the fact that quantifying the harm means assessing how the market in question would have evolved had there been no infringement. This assessment implies a comparison with a situation which is by definition hypothetical and can thus never be made with complete accuracy. It is therefore appropriate to ensure that national courts have the power to estimate the amount of the harm caused by the competition law infringement. Member States should ensure that, where requested, national competition authorities may provide guidance on quantum. In order to ensure coherence and predictability, the Commission should provide general guidance at Union level.
Recital 46, Directive (EU) 2014/104
Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar delivered on 7 April 2022. AD v PACCAR Inc and Others.Decision
As argued by the applicants in the main proceedings, a teleological interpretation of Directive 2014/104, which takes into account its purpose, must lead to the conclusion that it is necessary to apply the competition rules effectively …
7 Apr 2022 · 62021CC0163
Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 22 September 2022. Tráficos Manuel Ferrer S.L. and Ignacio v Daimler AG.Decision
As the applicants argue in the present case and as is apparent from recitals 14, 15, 45 and 46 of Directive 2014/104, the law governing antitrust damages is also characterised by a structural imbalance between the claimant – the injured …
22 Sep 2022 · 62021CC0312