For the purpose of protecting the right of shareholders and creditors, clear obligations should be laid down concerning the valuation of the assets and liabilities of the institution under resolution and, where required under this Directive, valuation of the treatment that shareholders and creditors would have received if the institution had been wound up under normal insolvency proceedings. It should be possible to commence a valuation already in the early intervention phase. Before any resolution action is taken, a fair and realistic valuation of the assets and liabilities of the institution should be carried out. Such a valuation should be subject to a right of appeal only together with the resolution decision. In addition, where required under this Directive, an ex-post comparison between the treatment that shareholders and creditors have actually been afforded and the treatment they would have received under normal insolvency proceedings should be carried out after resolution tools have been applied. If it is determined that shareholders and creditors have received, in payment of, or compensation for, their claims, the equivalent of less than the amount that they would have received under normal insolvency proceedings, they should be entitled to the payment of the difference where required under this Directive. As opposed to the valuation prior to the resolution action, it should be possible to challenge that comparison separately from the resolution decision. Member States should be free to decide on the procedure as to how to pay any difference of treatment that has been determined to shareholders and creditors. That difference, if any, should be paid by the financial arrangements established in accordance with this Directive.
Recital 51, Directive (EU) 2014/59
Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 5 May 2022. Banco Santander, SA v J.A.C. and M.C.P.R.Decision
Article 74 of that directive, read in the light of recital 51 of the same directive, establishes that for the purposes of assessing whether shareholders and creditors would have received better treatment if the credit institution or …
5 May 2022 · 62020CJ0410
Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour delivered on 2 December 2021. Banco Santander, SA v J.A.C. and M.C.P.R.Decision
Recitals 13, 49 to 51 and 120 of Directive 2014/59 state: The use of resolution tools and powers provided for in this Directive may disrupt the rights of shareholders and creditors. In particular, the power of the authorities to transfer …
2 Dec 2021 · 62020CC0410
Opinion of Advocate General Medina delivered on 12 December 2024. OF and Others v M.K.Decision
Recitals 3, 5, 10, 31, 48, 50, 51, 60 and 69 are relevant for the purposes of the present Opinion.
12 Dec 2024 · 62023CC0324