The principle of ne bis in idem is a fundamental principle of law in the Union, as recognised by the Charter and developed by the case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. Therefore the executing authority should be entitled to refuse the execution of an EIO if its execution would be contrary to that principle. Given the preliminary nature of the proceedings underlying an EIO, its execution should not be subject to refusal where it is aimed to establish whether a possible conflict with the ne bis in idem principle exists, or where the issuing authority has provided assurances that the evidence transferred as a result of the execution of the EIO would not be used to prosecute or impose a sanction on a person whose case has been finally disposed of in another Member State for the same facts.
Recital 17, Directive (EU) 2014/41
In forcesince 3 Apr 2014cited 2×
Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 19 November 2020. WS v Bundesrepublik Deutschland.Decision
Second, those two instruments also confirm that, for the blocking effect of the principle ne bis in idem to arise, there must be a final determination as to the actual application of that principle in relation to the specific case. Indeed, …
19 Nov 2020 · 62019CC0505
Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 12 May 2021. WS v Bundesrepublik Deutschland.Decision
Second, while, according to Article 11(1)(d) of Directive 2014/41, the execution of a European Investigation Order issued by a Member State may be refused in the executing Member State where such execution would be contrary to the ne bis …
12 May 2021 · 62019CJ0505