The French authorities argued that the parafiscal levy did not contain any discriminatory elements because it benefited:
In the first instance, the horse racing companies, and particularly those that constituted the PMU, the authorised betting operator. However, these companies gained no advantage, either financial or competitive, over other operators as this income was used solely and exclusively to finance the public service mission which was entrusted to them by the French authorities and which made no distinction according to the nationality of the participants in races.
Ultimately, and indirectly, all authorised betting operators whether French or foreign. They would benefit from the positive externalities of a high-quality and highly appealing race organisation.