Recital 44, Commission Decision of 15/07/2013 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

The Parties' combined share has constantly decreased during the past three years and will be below 50% post-transaction. In particular, GL's share has decreased overtime. As confirmed by the market investigation, GL's historically relatively strong market position can be explained by the fact that GL published the first industry accepted standards for wind turbines, and hence had in a way a first-mover advantage. However, other well-established TIC services providers have since then expanded their activities in this sector and continually increased their position in this segment. As a notable example, TÜV Rheinland, a large TIC organisation active in several industry sectors such as the energy sector and the automotive industry, has recently become accredited by DAkks for wind turbine certification [14] and, according to the Parties' estimate, has already been able to successfully contest [0-5]% of the EEA market. Moreover, TÜV Rheinland and Nippon Kaiji Kyokai recently announced a worldwide partnership in wind turbine certification, which is another illustration of the close interrelation of TIC services in different industry sectors. Finally, the Parties also submit that they will continue to face growing competition from a number of players in the EEA, such as TÜV Süd, TÜV Nord, UL/DEWI [15] and Bureau Veritas. The market investigation largely confirmed that these players are amongst the several wind turbine certification providers capable of offering comparable services to those of the Parties and that they will continue to do so post-transaction.