The Italian authorities and the 78 interested parties maintain that the specific activities carried on by non-commercial entities cannot be considered economic activities. In particular, they consider that, in the context of the ICI measure, activities such as assistance for young mothers in difficulty or management of a building in the mountains where children from a parish go on their summer holidays do not constitute an economic activity. These activities – targeting well-defined categories of recipients - do not constitute a supply of goods or services on the market by non-commercial entities and are not in competition with the activities performed by commercial undertakings. Therefore, these non-commercial entities, operating in the public interest, should not be considered undertakings, which is the prerequisite for the application of Article 107(1) of the Treaty. Moreover, according to the Italian authorities and some of the 78 interested parties, in many cases there is no actual market for such activities. Almost all of these activities also have specific characteristics, which can be summarised as follows:
they are provided free of charge or at reduced fees/prices;
they are provided for purposes of solidarity and social benefit, which fall outside the scope of commercial undertakings;
they have a reduced tax-paying capacity compared with commercial undertakings, which operate on market principles;
they generate deficits or low income; any profit must be reinvested in line with the entity’s objectives.